Renaissance

A Tournament Nobody Was Allowed to Attend

Pico offers to defend nine hundred theses in Rome and to pay for challengers’ travel. A papal inquiry turns the proposed disputation into a case to answer.

The invitation survives at the end of Pico’s printed theses. It shows what he meant to do in public and makes the distance between his plan and the proceedings that followed easier to see.

Orientation

At a Glance

  • An ordinary format grows to an unusual scalePublic disputation was familiar to scholars. Pico printed nine hundred propositions and offered to defend them at one event in Rome.
  • The printed notice is more specificPico’s announcement postpones the debate until after Epiphany. It promises to circulate the theses in Italian schools and to pay travel costs for challengers coming from across Italy.
  • A commission examines the thesesInnocent VIII appoints a commission that singles out thirteen propositions. Pico writes a defense, and the pope later bans the whole book.
  • The speech outlives the occasionPico’s proposed opening address survives even though the debate was canceled. Pater’s tournament image helps show what disappears when an invitation to speak becomes a case to answer.

Pater gives the whole Roman episode in a handful of sentences. “At last he came to Rome. There, like some knight-errant of philosophy, he offered to defend nine hundred bold paradoxes, drawn from the most opposite sources, against all comers. But the pontifical court was led to suspect the orthodoxy of some of these propositions, and even the reading of the book which contained them was forbidden by the Pope. It was not until 1493 that Pico was finally absolved, by a brief of Alexander the Sixth.” A page later he calls the event a “philosophical tournament,” and the image is lovely, a young knight riding into the city and nailing his challenge to the gate for any champion who dares to answer it.

The real event was both more ordinary and more extravagant than a joust. Propositions for public debate were a standard part of university life, and the Latin word Pico used was conclusiones, the normal term for theses put up for disputation, so Pater’s “bold paradoxes” turns a routine academic form into a provocation. What made it extraordinary was scale, since the little book printed in Rome on 7 December 1486 held nine hundred short theses drawn from many different traditions. Pico was twenty-three, and he had taken the ordinary seminar and blown it up to the size of a festival.

The scale of the invitation is where the chronology matters, because the story grew in the telling. The printed announcement at the end of the book says the theses won’t be disputed until after Epiphany, the feast on the sixth of January, that meanwhile they’ll be published in all the Italian universities, and that if any philosopher or theologian wants to come to Rome from the far ends of Italy, Pico will pay his travel expenses out of his own pocket. The nephew’s biography, in More’s translation, describes an offer to visitors from far countries. Pater’s “against all comers” suits the larger picture. The announcement’s travel pledge is specifically framed in terms of Italy.

Then the crowd was cancelled before it could gather. In February 1487 Pope Innocent VIII suspended the debate and set up a commission to examine the theses, and out of nine hundred it singled out thirteen, condemning seven and calling six suspect. Pico answered with a defense of those thirteen, his Apology, answering the charges in print. A bull dated 4 August 1487 then condemned the whole book, Pico fled to France, where he was detained at the pope’s request and briefly jailed, and the absolution Pater mentions didn’t come until 1493.

Pater compresses all of this into a polite passive voice, saying the court “was led to suspect” the orthodoxy of “some of these propositions,” and he leaves out the arrest entirely. Notice also how differently the two sides read the same document. Pico meant his theses to be spoken, explained and fought over in a room full of people, with the speech he wrote as an overture, while the commission examined them for conformity to doctrine. The setting made a difference to what counted as an answer. A thesis stripped of its disputation is like a chess move without the board, and it’s easy to find something sinister in it.

The comparison that makes this vivid comes thirty years later. In 1517 Martin Luther also proposed an academic disputation, on ninety-five theses about indulgences. Printed copies of his theses spread rapidly. Pico’s printed collection instead became the object of a ban, which prohibited readers from keeping or reading it. Print made Luther’s cancelled debate unstoppable, and it made Pico’s cancelled debate easy to bury.

So what does the cancellation change about the public life of Pico’s project? It gives the project the shape of a case. In place of the disputation Pico advertised, readers have the commission’s objections, Pico’s written defense and the order forbidding the book. Even the famous speech, meant to open the tournament, survived as a text without an occasion. The project’s reputation was set by the people who examined it and not by the people Pico had hoped to persuade, and that’s a fate no knight-errant expects when he rides in.

My verdict is that Pater’s image of the tournament is truer than he meant it to be. A knight-errant who arrives at the lists with his challenge posted and his opponents’ expenses paid, only to find the tournament banned by the lord of the castle and his own shield examined by the castle clerks, is a perfect picture of what happened in Rome. What the cancelled disputation changed was everything that matters about a public argument, since Pico’s ideas went into the world as charges answered on paper, and the generous scale of his invitation survives mainly in the size of the book that nobody was allowed to read.

Test your understanding

123

Question 1 of 3

Why does the article describe Pico’s undertaking as both ordinary and extraordinary?

Choose one answer

Guided Inquiry

Questions for Socrates

Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.