Renaissance

A Speech That Waited for Its Title

Pico wrote an opening speech for a debate that never took place. Its later title taught generations of readers what to look for.

The familiar title foregrounds Adam’s freedom. The occasion of the speech helps explain why Pico then spends so much time on how to use that freedom.

Orientation

At a Glance

  • A speech for an unrealized debatePico intended the oration to introduce his defense of 900 theses in Rome. The proposed disputation never took place.
  • Editors gave the speech its nameThe first edition praises the speech and gives it a running title tied to the Roman assembly. Later editions make human dignity part of its name.
  • Adam’s freedom opens the argumentPico’s Adam can sink to the level of beasts or rise toward God. The rest of the oration asks how to direct that freedom.
  • Where the ascent leadsCopenhaver reads the highest step as mystical union with God, which helps explain why the speech moves from self-formation to self-surrender.

Pater states the matter with complete confidence, in a sentence that leaves no room for doubt. “The oration which Pico composed for the opening of this philosophical tournament still remains; its subject is the dignity of human nature, the greatness of man.” The edition’s introduction is more careful, inviting readers to set Pater’s account beside the research on “the speech later called the Oration on the Dignity of Man,” and its note adds that the title is posthumous and that the famous opening on human freedom leads into a program of philosophical and spiritual ascent. So we have a speech that was never delivered and a title its author never used, which raises a question that sounds odd until you think about it, namely how a speech nobody heard comes to have a subject at all.

A speech that gets delivered takes its subject from its occasion, since the hall, the audience and the purpose of the day all tell you what it’s about. An undelivered one has only print, and print hands the job of naming it to editors. When Pico’s nephew published the text in Bologna in 1496, its opening called it a very elegant oration, and its running title identified it as a speech for the Roman assembly. The Strasbourg edition of 1504 used a heading about human dignity, and the familiar title appeared in the front matter of the Basel collection of 1557. By 1860 Jacob Burckhardt had closed a chapter of his great book on the Renaissance with it, as a crowning statement of the age’s discovery of man, and eleven years later Pater took the title’s word for its subject.

Under the dignity frame, readers fix on the opening pages, which really are electrifying. Pico quotes the old Hermetic saying that a human being is a great miracle, and then has God tell Adam that he alone among creatures has been given no fixed seat, no form and no function of his own, so that he can sink to the level of the beasts or rise toward the divine by his own choice, and Pico even calls humanity a chameleon for its power to become anything. Since the early nineteenth century, when the Kantian historian Wilhelm Tennemann took it up, readers have heard in this an anthem of self-making, and under that frame the long, learned remainder of the speech feels like the slow part after the hit single.

Under the occasion frame, the emphasis lands somewhere else entirely. The speech was written to introduce Pico’s defense of nine hundred theses, and most of it is about why anyone should climb and how. Pico urges his listeners to rival the cherubim, lays out a program in which moral philosophy purifies the soul, dialectic puts it in order, natural philosophy illuminates it and theology completes it, and leans on Jacob’s ladder and the old maxims carved at Delphi to make the case. Then he defends the study of every philosophical school, explains why he proposed so many theses at once, and introduces the Kabbalah, and in that light the opening on freedom stops being the point and becomes the premise of an argument.

The connection between the two halves is the real discovery here. A creature with no fixed nature isn’t safe anywhere, because the same freedom that lets you rise lets you fall to the beasts, so freedom in Pico’s opening is less a prize than a problem, and the rest of the speech is the solution, a program that tells you which way to use it. Where the program ends is the surprising part, and the historian Brian Copenhaver, whose reading the edition’s research note reports, argues that its goal is mystical union with God, in which the individual self has to be set aside, and in the oration Pico describes souls longing to die in themselves so that they can live in their beloved. The famous freedom turns out to be the freedom to give the self away.

The other side deserves its due, and it has a strong case. A text’s meaning isn’t owned forever by the occasion it was written for, and nobody forced Pico to open with Adam, so readers who are gripped by that passage are responding to something he chose to put first. The dignity reading has also done real moral work over the centuries, as a defense of human possibility against every system that says people are fixed by birth. The research note itself calls Copenhaver’s interpretation forcefully argued rather than settled, and Pater’s own creed, that nothing which has interested living minds wholly loses its vitality, makes the dignity reading part of the speech’s life now, whatever Pico intended.

Pater, interestingly, half reads the speech both ways, since he accepts the title’s subject and then spends the next page arguing with it, complaining that Pico’s theory of dignity rested on a false picture of the earth’s place in the universe, so he engages the speech as a treatise on human greatness. Yet elsewhere in the chapter he senses exactly where Pico’s ascent was heading, describing a change that came over him “as if the chilling touch of the abstract and disembodied beauty Platonists profess to long for were already upon him.” That chill belongs to the occasion frame, to a program whose summit is self-surrender, and Pater feels it in the life even while he follows the title in the text.

My verdict is that an undelivered speech acquires its subject from its editors and readers precisely because it never had a room to fix its point, and the dignity title is a legitimate afterlife and a misleading summary. Read in light of the debate, the opening on freedom is the first rung of a ladder. In Copenhaver’s reading, the ladder ends in the soul’s surrender of itself to God. The most honest description of the speech is that it’s about how a creature with no fixed nature ought to climb, and about what it has to stop being when it reaches the top, with dignity as the starting point and not the destination.

Test your understanding

123

Question 1 of 3

How does the article distinguish the “dignity frame” from the “occasion frame”?

Choose one answer

Guided Inquiry

Questions for Socrates

Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.