Greek Antiquity
A Soundtrack for the Sun
A bull-roarer, a lyre, a pipe, and a whip give the sun’s course its own set of sounds.
The Orphic Collection, Volume I: The HymnsHelios rushes across the sky with sounds of speed and a golden lyre associated with cosmic harmony. The article asks how music can describe the order of his motion.
Orientation
At a Glance
- The journey sounds fastThe bull-roarer’s whirl and the sharp sound of the whip help the reader hear the chariot’s speed.
- One sound is an editor’s readingAbel supplies the word translated whirring where the manuscripts give a different word.
- The lyre gives the journey orderThe hymn associates the golden lyre with the harmonious course of the kosmos.
- Helios also pipesThe title piper places a quieter musical sound alongside the fire, spirals, and horses.
Orphic Hymns, VIII.6–11, 18–19, with the apparatus and the notes on VIII.7 and VIII.9
Most hymns to the sun are about light, and this one is, but read it aloud and you notice how loud it is. The sun is “whirring” at line 6, he drives his track “in the whirlings of an endless rhombos” at line 7, at line 9 he is “of the golden lyre, drawing the harmonious course of the kosmos,” at line 11 he’s a “piper,” and at the end he urges his four horses “with the shrill whip.” That’s five sounds in fourteen lines, so the sun’s daily journey arrives with a soundtrack, and the question is what kind of soundtrack it is and how the pieces fit together.
Some of the noises are rough, and the whirring is the sound of speed, the rush of a chariot or a thrown spear cutting the air, though the apparatus notes that the word is Abel’s and that the manuscripts give something quite different there, so this particular sound is partly an editor’s contribution. The rhombos, as the note says, is “the bull-roarer whirled on its cord,” and if you hear the instrument behind the word you hear a deep throbbing roar. These are the noises of power in motion, the soundtrack of an engine rather than of an orchestra.
Then there’s the whip, and it’s more musical than you’d expect. The adjective is ligyros, which the edition renders “shrill” and which in Greek is a word for clear, carrying sound, used of the wind in the reeds and, most famously, of the song of the Sirens in the Odyssey. So the crack of the sun’s whip is described with a singer’s word, a sharp clear note rather than a mere snap, which is a lovely touch. The sun’s driving has a voice, and it’s a voice that carries across the whole sky. It’s a fine example of how this collection rarely lets a merely practical object stay merely practical, since even the whip, the least poetic thing in a chariot, gets an adjective borrowed from song.
The piper is a surprise. Syriktēs means one who plays the syrinx, the shepherd’s pipe of Pan, or simply one who whistles, and it sits in a line otherwise made of fire and circling, “world-ruler, piper, fire-coursing, wheeling in spirals.” Perhaps it’s the high whistle of something moving very fast, perhaps it’s the shepherd’s music of a sun who watches over flocks and fields, and the hymn doesn’t say which. Either way, the sun now has a wind instrument as well as a string instrument and a percussion section, which is starting to sound like a whole band on the move. Greek processions really did travel this way, with pipers and lyre-players walking ahead of the sacrificial animals and the dignitaries, so the image of a god moving through the sky to music would have looked to the hymn’s hearers like the festivals they knew, scaled up to the size of the heavens.
At the center of it all is the golden lyre, and this is where the hymn gets careful. Helios is “of the golden lyre, drawing the harmonious course of the kosmos,” and the note calls this the music of the spheres “stated in four words and not elaborated.” The lyre belongs to Apollo, with whom the sun was often identified, and the word for harmonious, enarmonion, comes from the language of tuning, of things fitted together in the right intervals. The sun’s path through the sky is in tune, and the lyre in his hand is the sign of that.
But notice what the line doesn’t say, since it never claims the sun plays the lyre to move the world, or that the cosmos turns because of the music, and the edition’s notes draw attention to the same restraint elsewhere, when Pan strikes out the harmony of the world “in song” with no instrument named. The lyre is named beside the act rather than as its means, an emblem rather than an engine. Plato had a fuller version in the myth of Er, where each of the heavenly circles carries a Siren singing a single note, and the eight notes together make one harmony, but the hymn gives us only the bare idea, a course that is musical in its order.
So the noises fit together in a particular way. The rough ones, the whirring and the roar and the whip, belong to the journey’s force and speed, and the refined ones, the lyre and the harmonious course, belong to its order and proportion, while the pipe hovers somewhere between. The picture is less like a concert than like a festival procession, with a chariot thundering through and musicians playing alongside, and the music is part of the procession’s dignity without being what pulls the chariot. The musicians in a parade make it a celebration rather than a commute, and that’s roughly the role the hymn gives its lyre and pipe. Pulling the chariot is still the job of the horses and the driver, and the hymn never confuses the two.
My verdict is that the hymn gives the sun several sounds because it imagines his course as a great public event, loud and fast and also beautifully ordered, and that it’s right to keep the lyre an attribute rather than a mechanism. What the “harmonious course” lets us say is that the sun’s motion has the qualities of music, measure and fitness and beauty, without claiming that the music does the moving. The cosmos in this hymn sounds wonderful, but it runs on horses and a whip, and the lyre is there to tell you that the running is in tune.
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 3
How does the article interpret the golden lyre’s relationship to the sun’s movement?
Guided Inquiry
Questions for Socrates
Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.
- What is gained—and what might be lost—by reading the hymn’s mixture of rough and refined sounds as a festival procession rather than as a concert or an engine?→
- Why does the distinction between the lyre as an emblem and as a mechanism matter for the article’s interpretation of cosmic harmony?→
- How does describing the practical whip with language associated with song change your understanding of the sun’s power and daily journey?→