Renaissance
A Short Career Measured Against a Long One
Pater compares Giorgione and Titian to Browning’s Sordello and Dante. A few surviving works can tell us a great deal about an artist, even when a longer career goes somewhere they could never have predicted.
The Renaissance (1893)Browning’s invented fragment gives Pater a way to describe Giorgione’s concentrated achievement. The work Titian made over the next sixty years tests the analogy.
Orientation
At a Glance
- Pater compares careersPater sees in Giorgione’s few remaining works a version of what Titian developed over another six decades.
- A fragment in BrowningAt the close of Sordello, a boy sings a few words from the poet’s Goito lay. Pater takes that imagined remnant as an analogy.
- Painters share a historyMichiel reports work by more than one hand in pictures linked with Giorgione, and the Pitti Concert is now attributed to Titian.
- The room a long life givesLate pictures such as Titian’s Pietà show how a painter can change the possibilities he inherited.
The Renaissance · The School of Giorgione, p. 94, Giorgione and Titian · The School of Giorgione, note 217
Pater lines up two careers that could hardly look more different. Titian “lives in constant labour more than sixty years after Giorgione is in his grave,” and with such results “that hardly one of the greater towns of Europe is without some fragment of his work,” while Giorgione’s surviving output, “when narrowly explained,” seems “to reduce itself to almost one picture, like Sordello’s one fragment of lovely verse.” The numbers hold up, since Giorgione died in 1510 and Titian in 1576. Then Pater reaches for a literary comparison, saying Giorgione stands to Titian “in something like the relationship of Sordello to Dante, in Browning’s poem,” and the comparison tells you a lot about what he thinks a short career is worth.
Browning’s Sordello came out in 1840 and quickly gained a reputation for difficulty. The same promise that a reader might hear Sordello’s story appears in different forms at its opening and close. The real Sordello was a thirteenth-century troubadour from Goito near Mantua whom Dante meets in Purgatorio VI, where he embraces Virgil as a fellow Mantuan, and Browning turned him into a poet who glimpses what poetry could become and never quite achieves it, a forerunner standing in the shadow of the man who would. In Dante the meeting is brief and charged, since the sight of two Mantuans embracing sets off the poet’s great outburst against a divided Italy, Ahi serva Italia, “ah, enslaved Italy,” so Sordello’s job in the Commedia is to be a moment of fellow feeling that the bigger poet turns into a sermon.
The fragment Pater mentions is one of the loveliest touches in the poem. At the very end Browning sends a peasant boy up a hillside near Goito, singing “some unintelligible words,” and what he’s singing turns out to be a scrap of Sordello’s old song about a girl’s hair, “the few fine locks / Stained like pale honey oozed from topmost rocks / Sun-blanched the livelong summer,” after which Browning adds, “all that’s left / Of the Goito lay!” In Browning’s fiction that song survives as a few half-understood lines in a child’s mouth, which is exactly how Pater feels about Giorgione, a whole art boiled down to a few bright traces that strangers still sing without knowing the words.
The comparison makes a real and interesting claim about fragments. The older man, Pater says, “yet expresses, in elementary motive and principle,” the spirit “which Titian spreads over his whole life’s activity,” and that’s a claim about concentration, the idea that a short career can hold in compressed form what a long one unfolds. Pater adds that Titian, after leaving Bellini, “becomes, in turn, the pupil of Giorgione,” a way of describing an influence that does not establish how formally the painters worked together. It’s the same logic as the old line about a band whose first album sold almost nothing but seemed to start a hundred other bands, where the small original is valued as a seed and not as a sample. Pater also calls that spirit “itself the final acquisition of all the long endeavours of Venetian art,” so in his account Giorgione is both a beginning and an end, the place where Bellini’s long tradition arrives and Titian’s career sets out.
The first problem with the comparison is plain hindsight. A fragment looks like an anticipation only because we already know what came after it, so we read Sordello through Dante and Giorgione through Titian and then congratulate the earlier man for foreseeing what we’ve just read into him, which is like praising a rookie season for predicting a Hall of Fame career that hadn’t happened yet. Nobody in 1508 could have looked at Giorgione and seen the late Titian coming, any more than a listener in 1250 could have heard the Commedia in a troubadour’s song. Pater’s word “anticipation” isn’t on the page, but the structure of the comparison does the anticipating for him.
The second problem is that the two careers leak into each other. Michiel, writing in the 1520s, credits Titian with the landscape and Cupid of a sleeping Venus by Giorgione and says Sebastiano finished the Three Philosophers. The one picture Pater thought certain, the Pitti Concert, is now given to the young Titian. So the short career is partly built out of the long one, and measuring Giorgione against Titian turns out to be a bit like measuring a river against the lake it runs into, since some of the water you’re counting belongs to both.
The third problem is that the comparison is unfair to Titian. “Spreads” makes his sixty years sound like butter thinned across too much bread, and that’s simply wrong about the late work. The Flaying of Marsyas and the Pietà left unfinished at Titian’s death have dark and broken surfaces far removed from the early works Pater sets beside Giorgione. A long life gave Titian room to test and change what he inherited. Dante, for that matter, did a great deal more than finish Sordello’s thoughts.
My verdict is that Pater’s comparison is right about concentration and wrong about anticipation. A short career can state a principle with a purity a long one rarely keeps, which is why a few Giorgiones still feel like a key to a whole school, but only a long life can test that principle against age, failure and change, which is what Titian’s sixty years were for. We should value Giorgione the way Browning’s last lines value Sordello, as a concentrate whose beauty doesn’t depend on what came after, and stop asking him to have predicted a career that wasn’t his. The honest version of Pater’s comparison is simpler and still beautiful, that some artists give you a few perfect lines and others give you a lifetime, and that the first kind isn’t a rough draft of the second.
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 3
What is the central value Pater’s comparison assigns to Giorgione’s short career?
Guided Inquiry
Questions for Socrates
Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.
- If Giorgione’s work is valued as a concentrated artistic principle, what standards could distinguish genuine concentration from a career that was merely cut short?→
- How does knowing what came later shape our interpretation of an earlier artist, and can critics ever avoid that hindsight completely?→
- Does the author’s final distinction between “a few perfect lines” and “a lifetime” successfully avoid ranking Giorgione and Titian, or does it still privilege one kind of achievement?→