Renaissance

A Prize for a Kiss and a List That Proves Too Much

Winckelmann gathers reports of beauty prizes, priesthoods and kisses. The ancient texts attach those honours to quite different occasions.

A beautiful youth might serve a god, receive a cult after death or win a contest. The reasons these stories give are more varied than the theory Winckelmann builds from them.

Orientation

At a Glance

  • The list gathers different customsWinckelmann puts a drinking song, priesthoods and athletic or social competitions in one argument about how Greeks valued beauty.
  • A role with more than one requirementPausanias says the Theban priest of Ismenian Apollo was chosen for beauty and strength as well as family standing.
  • A shrine for a former enemyHerodotus says the people of Egesta made offerings at the grave of Philip of Croton, whom they had fought.
  • A kiss in remembranceThe poem attributed to Theocritus describes a kissing contest at Diocles’ grave, giving the prize a setting of remembrance.

Winckelmann’s paragraph on Greek beauty reads like one of those lists that go around online under a title like “Ten Facts That Prove the Greeks Were Obsessed with Looks,” and Pater copies it out in full just after saying that in Greece “Beauty becomes a distinction, like genius, or noble place.” The list opens with a sweeping claim, “By no people,” Winckelmann writes, “has beauty been so highly esteemed as by the Greeks,” and then piles up priests chosen for beauty, a shrine for a handsome foreigner, a drinking song, a nickname, beauty contests and “a prize” for “the deftest kiss.” The question is what a collector’s list like this can actually prove, and which of its ancient reports a careful reader would need to look up before trusting the theory built on top of them.

Some of the evidence is solid and well attested. The travel writer Pausanias says that at Thebes, even in his own day, a boy of good family who was both handsome and strong served each year as priest of Ismenian Apollo, and he also says that at Aegium in the old days the most beautiful boy was chosen as priest of Zeus until his beard began to grow, after which the honor passed to another boy (Winckelmann’s “Ægæ” seems to be a slip for Aegium). At Tanagra, he says, the youth judged most handsome carried a lamb around the city walls at the festival of Hermes. These are local customs in which beauty counted in public worship. Pausanias wrote in the second century CE and distinguishes the customs of his own day from ones he understood to be older.

Context changes the picture, though, even for these well-attested customs. The Tanagra procession recalled a story that Hermes had once saved the city from a plague by carrying a ram around its walls, so the handsome youth was reenacting a protective rite against disease, and the Theban priest needed a good family and a strong body as well as a good face. Beauty was one requirement in a package, the way a homecoming king usually needs the right friends and the right team as much as the right jawline.

The Egesta story needs the most context of all. Herodotus says that Philip of Croton, an Olympic victor and the handsomest Greek of his time, sailed with the Spartan prince Dorieus to Sicily and was killed there in battle against the Carthaginians and the people of Egesta. Afterward the Egestans built a hero’s shrine over his grave and offered him sacrifices of propitiation because of his beauty, an honor they gave to nobody else. Winckelmann’s “not their fellow-citizen” is a polite way of saying that he was one of the enemies they’d helped kill, and the sacrifices involve how a community honours its dead as well as what it admired about this man.

The smaller items in the list wobble when you look them up. A drinking song and a nickname are different sorts of evidence from a priesthood. Athenaeus records a contest founded by Cypselus, whose city included Parrhasian settlers. That may be one custom described from two angles in Winckelmann’s list. Athenaeus also reports contests in other places, but their details and settings vary.

The kiss is the best story and the least about looks. The twelfth idyll attributed to Theocritus describes how the young people of Megara compete in kissing at Diocles’ grave every spring. The winner goes home with garlands. The poem gives the contest a grave and a person to remember, which changes what the prize can mean.

The weakest links in the chain are the two that the theory needs most. Winckelmann says beautiful people sought “above all to approve himself to the artists, because they awarded the prize,” which would give sculptors a steady parade of models, and he infers that contests were meant to promote “the procreation of beautiful children.” The reports above do little to establish either inference. Winckelmann builds the bridge from custom to the sculptor’s practice himself.

My verdict is that the list works as a mood board but not as proof. It shows that beauty could be publicly marked in Greek religion and civic life, with consequences particular to each setting. Read in context, though, the reports tie beauty to plague rites, a slain enemy’s ghost, a lover’s tomb and a courtesan’s joke, which is the sombre world Pater himself described two pages earlier, where Greek religion was full of sadness and fear, so the evidence fits his darker account of the Greeks better than the sunny theory it was drafted to support.

Test your understanding

123

Question 1 of 3

Why does the author treat the Tanagra procession as more complicated evidence than a simple celebration of physical beauty?

Choose one answer

Guided Inquiry

Questions for Socrates

Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.