Philosophy

A Name in Search of Its Thing

Socrates knows the word ‘temperance’ and believes it names a great good. By the end of the dialogue, he still can’t say what that good is.

Socrates ends with a familiar name and no settled account of what it names. Water, jade, and phlogiston offer three ways to think about that predicament.

Orientation

At a Glance

  • A familiar nameSocrates and Critias can use the word ‘temperance’ and discuss examples, but their inquiry still hasn’t established what the word names.
  • The name as a toolIn the Cratylus, Socrates compares making a name to making a shuttle. The person who knows how to ask and answer questions can judge whether the name has been well made.
  • Three ways a word can workA familiar word can name one thing we haven’t understood yet, group different things together, or name something we’ve mistakenly supposed to exist.
  • What the search leaves openSocrates remains convinced that temperance is a great good. The failed definitions leave open what that good is and whether its familiar examples have one feature in common.

Charmides 174d–175b, 175b–176a · Cratylus 388e–389d, 390c–d · Hilary Putnam The Meaning of ‘Meaning’ · Geoscience Australia Jade · Antoine Lavoisier The Nature of Combustion

When the argument finally collapses, Socrates describes the defeat in an interesting way. “As it is,” he says, “we are beaten on every side, and cannot discover to which of the things that are the lawgiver gave this name, temperance.” It’s as if they’re holding a luggage tag and can’t locate the suitcase. The image tells us what he thinks an inquiry into a virtue ought to find.

The lawgiver here is the person who gives things their names, a figure Socrates and Hermogenes discuss in the Cratylus. There the name-maker is a craftsman. A carpenter makes a shuttle suited to its work, and the lawgiver makes a name suited to what it is meant to name. Socrates adds that the person who should supervise the name-maker is the dialectician, the person who knows how to ask and answer questions. On that picture, Socrates and Critias have spent the afternoon trying to do the dialectician’s job. By the end they still can’t say what would make temperance a fitting name for any of the things they’ve discussed.

The phrase “to which of the things that are” suggests that there’s one thing already wearing this name and that the job is to find it. Familiar words can work in several ways. A word may pick out a real thing we haven’t learned to define. It may cover different things we’ve grouped together. It may also name something we have only supposed to exist.

The first possibility is the most encouraging for Socrates. The philosopher Hilary Putnam imagines people on Earth in 1750 using the word ‘water’ before they know what water is made of. On his account they still refer to the substance we now describe as H₂O. If ‘temperance’ works like that, its familiar use might already give us a real subject to investigate. The difficulty would be finding out what the admired examples have in common.

The second possibility is more unsettling. Jade is a name we use for materials that can look alike, including two minerals, jadeite and nephrite, with different compositions and structures. Sōphrosynē might be like jade. Quietness, modesty, doing one’s own business, and self-knowledge might be different things people have praised with one word. In that case the question of what got the name could have more than one answer.

The third possibility is the bleakest. Chemists working in Stahl’s tradition explained burning by supposing that combustible things contained phlogiston. Lavoisier argued that the phenomena could be explained without supposing that the material contained phlogiston. A word can be widely used and still leave open whether what it names exists. Socrates, for his part, says he believes temperance is a great good. The example shows how little the familiarity of the word alone can tell him.

So what does familiar moral vocabulary give us? It gives us a topic, examples to talk about, and a sense of what people are praising when they use the word. That’s enough to begin. The Charmides also shows what can happen after we begin. Each definition seems to catch part of what people admire, and several of them survive long enough to make the jade possibility worth taking seriously.

My verdict is that Socrates is right to describe the defeat as a failure to identify what they’ve been looking for. He knows how people use the word and how much value they put on it. Whether they’re talking about one thing, several related things, or a good they’ve misunderstood is still the work of the inquiry.

Test your understanding

123

Question 1 of 3

Why does the article describe Socrates and Critias as attempting the dialectician’s job?

Choose one answer

Guided Inquiry

Questions for Socrates

Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.