Renaissance
A Name Dropped Beside a Stain
Pater hears admiration in Leonardo’s mention of Botticelli. The passage itself is a disagreement about what painters can learn from a stain.
The Renaissance (1893)A paint-soaked sponge gives Leonardo a way to distinguish finding an idea from knowing how to finish a painting. Pater’s own Botticelli helps us see what both artists found in the blot.
Orientation
At a Glance
- Pater hears a recommendationPater suggests that Leonardo’s mention of Botticelli may reflect a deliberate judgment in his favor.
- Leonardo gives a counterexampleIn the treatise, Leonardo says Botticelli thought studying landscape was unnecessary and criticizes the landscapes he painted.
- What a stain can teachLeonardo grants that a stain can suggest landscapes, faces and battles. He thinks finishing those inventions requires skills the stain cannot provide.
- Why the anecdote fits Pater’s painterA blot that can suggest a world makes a fitting introduction to the Botticelli Pater admires for turning appearances into visions.
The Renaissance · Sandro Botticelli, Leonardo’s mention of Botticelli · Note 84, the reference in Leonardo’s treatise · Sandro Botticelli, the painter as visionary · Sandro Botticelli, Venus at a sunless dawn · Leonardo, Treatise on Painting, the Botticelli passage · Leonardo’s Treatise on Painting, Vatican manuscript · Pliny, Natural History XXXV.101–104, Protogenes and the sponge · Patrizia Zambrano on Leonardo’s sponge and Pliny · Max Ernst on Leonardo and frottage, Guggenheim retrospective catalogue
Pater’s first sentence is a small piece of salesmanship. Leonardo’s treatise on painting, he tells us, mentions just one contemporary by name, and that one is Botticelli. “This pre-eminence may be due to chance only, but to some will rather appear a result of deliberate judgment; for people have begun to find out the charm of Botticelli’s work, and his name, little known in the last century, is quietly becoming important.” The hint is clear enough, since if the greatest mind of the age singled out one fellow painter, perhaps the choice was a verdict, and a reader who is about to spend twenty pages on a half-forgotten artist is being told that Leonardo himself would approve.
The treatise isn’t a book Leonardo finished, since it was compiled after his death by his pupil and heir Francesco Melzi from passages scattered through the notebooks, survives in a manuscript in the Vatican, and was first printed, in an abridged form, in Paris in 1651. The edition’s note tells us where the Botticelli reference sits, in a discussion of landscape and of the images one can make out in a stained wall. Leonardo argues there that a painter isn’t universal unless he loves every part of his art equally, and offers a counterexample, “our Botticelli,” who said that studying landscape was a waste of time, since you could throw a sponge soaked in different colors at a wall and see a fine landscape in the stain it left. That “our” is worth noticing, because the two men had moved through the same circle of Florentine workshops in the 1470s, and Leonardo speaks of him the way you’d speak of a colleague you used to argue with.
Leonardo grants that a stain can suggest inventions, but he insists that it won’t teach you to finish anything, and he ends with a crushing line, that this painter made tristissimi paesi, very wretched landscapes. So the one contemporary named in the treatise appears as an example of what not to do. Pater either didn’t know the context or chose not to share it, and his cautious “may be due to chance only” leaves room for both. Either way, the mention ranks Botticelli nowhere in particular, unless being singled out for a scolding counts as a compliment, which it sometimes does, since nobody bothers to argue with a painter who doesn’t matter.
The quarrel is more interesting than either man’s verdict, because both accounts allow a stain to suggest a landscape. Leonardo himself famously advised painters to look at walls marked with damp and discoloration, where they would find mountains, battles and strange faces waiting to be developed, so the two artists agreed that a blot can hold a world. They disagreed about what that meant for painting, because Botticelli took it as proof that landscape was easy, a thing chance could do, while Leonardo took it as a starting point that demanded long study to bring to completion, which is exactly the difference between a man who wanted to know how mountains are made and a man who wanted to make a mood.
Botticelli’s remark has a parallel in an ancient story about painting, since Pliny tells how the Greek painter Protogenes, unable to get the foam on a panting dog’s mouth right, threw his sponge at the picture in a rage, and the sponge left exactly the foam he had failed to paint. The art historian Patrizia Zambrano links Botticelli’s sponge to that anecdote. It makes the painter’s remark sound like a joke about what chance can do, though Leonardo’s account leaves open what Botticelli had in mind. Leonardo answered the joke with a lecture, which is very much the Leonardo we know from the notebooks, unable to let an amusing exaggeration pass without turning it into a problem in method.
Here is why the stain makes such an apt opening for Pater’s Botticelli. A few pages later Pater describes him as a visionary whose genius “usurps the data before it as the exponent of ideas, moods, visions of its own,” rejecting some details, isolating others and always combining them anew. A painter who could see a whole landscape in a splash of paint is precisely a painter for whom appearances are triggers for moods rather than things to be recorded. Max Ernst later linked the idea to his practice of frottage, making rubbings from textured surfaces. In his account, an intense fascination with the grain of a wooden floor helped him find a way to put Leonardo’s advice into practice.
Then there’s that word tristissimi, which deserves a second look. In Leonardo’s Italian tristo could mean poor, mean or wretched, which is surely what he meant, but it shares its root with triste, sad, and a reader who knows Pater’s essay can hardly hear it without a jolt. Pater’s whole Botticelli is a painter of sadness, of figures with “a sentiment of ineffable melancholy” and of the cold sea in the Birth of Venus, lit by what he calls “mere sunless dawn.” Leonardo meant to say that Botticelli painted landscapes badly, and he left behind, by accident, a two-word summary of what the nineteenth century would come to love in him.
My verdict is that Leonardo’s reference gives scant evidence of any ranking, since it’s a rebuke between colleagues, and that Leonardo’s passage gives Pater’s hint of deliberate esteem little support. Botticelli was finding a new audience in nineteenth-century Britain, and Pater’s essay is part of that renewed attention. Yet the context Pater skipped makes a better overture than the one he wrote, a quarrel over a stain between a perfectionist who wanted landscapes finished and a visionary who thought a splash could hold a world, ending with a word that means both wretched and sad.
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 3
According to the article, what rhetorical purpose does Pater’s opening claim about Leonardo serve?
Guided Inquiry
Questions for Socrates
Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.
- How does learning the critical context of Leonardo’s reference change the persuasive force of Pater’s opening, and does it weaken or enrich Pater’s portrait of Botticelli?→
- If both Leonardo and Botticelli believed that accidental marks could suggest images, what does their disagreement reveal about their different ideas of artistic labor and completion?→
- When a word acquires meanings its original speaker did not intend, as with Leonardo’s description of Botticelli’s landscapes, how should later readers balance historical meaning against interpretive resonance?→