Philosophy
A Motto Isn’t an Answer
Critias invokes Delphi. Socrates asks what it means to know yourself and what good that knowledge does.
The Platonic Dialogues: CharmidesThe inscription gives Critias a celebrated formula. A doctor, a builder and a geometer help Socrates find out how much of a definition it gives him.
Orientation
At a Glance
- Delphi enters the argumentCritias gives up his earlier account and offers to defend temperance as knowing oneself. He connects the new account to the inscription at Apollo’s temple.
- Socrates is willing to find outSocrates says he inquires because he doesn’t know. He’ll decide whether he agrees after he has looked into what Critias proposes.
- Two questions about knowledgeCritias names oneself as the object. Socrates asks what that means in practice and what benefit this knowledge brings.
- Geometry changes the testCritias points out that geometry has no product like a builder’s house. Socrates grants the point and asks what geometry or calculation is about, keeping the question of what temperance knows open.
Critias plays his trump card with a flourish, the way a lawyer saves his star witness for last. Everything before this, he says, “I give up to you,” and he’s ready to make his case “if you do not agree that temperance is knowing oneself.” He has just tied that definition to the inscription at Delphi. Disagreeing with him now might sound a little like disagreeing with Apollo. Socrates takes the claim seriously enough to ask what it means.
He starts with the terms of the inquiry. Critias is talking to him, he says, “as though I claimed to know the answers to what I ask, and as though I will agree with you if only I want to.” Socrates says he inquires together with the person who makes the proposal because he doesn’t know himself. He’ll say whether he agrees once he’s looked into it. In a contest, you try to get the other person to give way. Here the person asking questions has something to find out too.
Socrates asks whether knowing something would have to be “a kind of knowledge, and knowledge of something.” Critias says it’s “knowledge of oneself.” That gives him a first answer. Socrates turns to the crafts to see what such knowledge might do. Medicine knows about health and produces health, “a fine work for us.” House-building produces houses. If knowledge of oneself is a virtue, what good work can we say it does?
These are the kinds of questions an authoritative formula can leave open. A company can put a promise of excellence and integrity on a poster. Then an employee discovers a defect in something a customer is about to buy. The words might have a bearing on what to tell the customer, but the employee still has to decide what they ask of her. Telling a teenager to be himself can leave him in the same spot. The advice points in a direction and leaves him to find out which part of himself to trust.
In the Apology, Socrates says he was puzzled when the oracle told his friend Chaerephon that no one was wiser than Socrates. He expected the god to be telling the truth and couldn’t see how it fit his own estimate of what he knew. So he went to talk to someone reputed wise. Taking Delphi seriously meant doing something about the puzzle. Here Socrates can question the person who has just offered an interpretation of Delphi to him.
Critias’ objection to the craft analogy makes the inquiry better. A geometer doesn’t leave a house behind, and calculation has no product of that sort either. Socrates grants it. He can still say what calculation is concerned with, such as even and odd numbers and their relations. That turns the question back to temperance. Critias has said its object is oneself, and now he has to say what about oneself is known and whether it’s the same sort of object a craft has. The question about the benefit can stay open without requiring a product you can point to.
Critias has added prestige to his account. Explaining it takes a different kind of work. The inscription is like an envelope marked urgent. The stamp gives you a reason to open it. Once you have, you still need to read what’s inside and decide what it asks of you. The moment Socrates asks for examples, Critias has to give reasons a person could examine even if they had never been to Delphi.
My verdict is that the response takes a famous motto exactly as seriously as it deserves. It lets Critias say what he thinks the words ask of us, and then asks him to show it. At the end of the exchange, the answer ‘oneself’ has a little more work to do than it did at the beginning. A reader can start in the same place by asking what he expects to learn and what he’d do differently if he learned it.
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 3
How does Socrates distinguish their inquiry from a contest?
Guided Inquiry
Questions for Socrates
Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.
- If Socrates does not know the answer himself, what gives his questions the power to test Critias’s definition?→
- What would someone need to specify before “knowing oneself” could guide a concrete decision?→
- When does appealing to an authoritative motto deepen an inquiry, and when might it prevent inquiry?→