Renaissance

A Map Drawn in Verbs

The outline tells readers what Pater does with his subjects. Its verbs offer a way to follow him from an act of looking to a larger idea.

Biography, attribution and the handling of materials call for different kinds of attention. The outline shows how each can begin a Pater essay.

Orientation

At a Glance

  • What the critic doesThe outline begins with a reader who distinguishes, describes and traces the effect of a particular work.
  • Different objects require different toolsTracing Botticelli’s recurring faces takes a different kind of attention from reading Luca della Robbia through marble and glazed terracotta.
  • A question can open into anotherThe question of who painted a work in the Giorgione essay leads into a larger inquiry about style and the unity of music.
  • The last applicationIn the outline’s account of the Conclusion, the attention that begins with works of art turns toward the passing moments of a life.

Most outlines are tables of contents with a few adjectives added, the kind that tell you chapter three is about a painter and chapter four is about a sculptor. This one starts somewhere else, with a person doing something rather than a subject being covered. “The critic starts with the effect of a particular work,” it says of the Preface, and then it asks how that effect “can be distinguished, described, and traced to its source.” The grammatical subject of the very first sentence is the critic, and the verbs are acts of reading, so before the outline has named a single painter it has told you that the book is going to be organized around things a reader does.

Walk through the entries and the verbs keep that promise. In the French stories Pater “looks for an early revival of imaginative freedom,” with Pico “the life of a young scholar becomes a study of the desire to reconcile traditions,” and with Botticelli “Pater follows recurring faces and attitudes” through picture after picture, the way a fan spots the same actor turning up in different films. With Luca he “reads the choices of a sculptor through material, colour, and the handling of ordinary movement,” while Michelangelo’s sonnets “give Pater a way to read the forces he sees held in the sculpture.” In the Giorgione entry “the problem of attribution opens into a discussion of style,” for Du Bellay “French poetry meets classical and Italian models,” with Winckelmann “Pater moves between the conditions of that life” and his tastes, and at the end “the attention asked of a critic is applied to time and experience.”

Line those verbs up and they fall into two families. One family has Pater as its subject, looking for, following, reading, moving between, and those are verbs of perception and search. The other family has the material itself as its subject, a life that “becomes” a study, a problem that “opens into” a discussion, Rome that “yields” a poetry, attention that “is applied” to time, and those are verbs of transformation. Almost every entry contains one of each, which tells you something true about the shape of a Pater essay, since each one starts with an act of looking and then turns, somewhere in the middle, into an argument about something larger than the object it started from.

The verbs also show how far Pater’s method changes from chapter to chapter, which a list of subjects would hide. Pico and Winckelmann get biography, a life read as an idea. Botticelli gets something close to iconography, faces tracked across a body of work, and Luca gets a study of materials, marble against glazed clay. Michelangelo and Giorgione get reading across the arts, poems through sculpture and paintings through music, and Giorgione adds the connoisseur’s problem of who painted what. Du Bellay gets cultural contact, and the Conclusion gets ethics. The Preface promised a single method, but the outline shows a critic who changes tools with every job. Even the Conclusion fits the pattern, since its entry treats an ethical essay as one more application of the critic’s attention, which is a neat way of making the book’s most famous pages continuous with its quietest ones.

It’s worth noticing how the outline compresses the Preface itself. Pater says the critic’s task is “to distinguish, to analyse, and separate from its adjuncts, the virtue” of a work and “to indicate what the source of that impression is,” with a chemist as his model. The outline keeps the first and last steps and swaps the chemistry in the middle for a plainer word. It asks how the effect can be “distinguished, described, and traced to its source.” That’s a quiet but real interpretation, since it presents Pater’s method as description rather than laboratory analysis, and lets the reader see what the comparison with a chemist is meant to clarify.

Two entries are especially candid about where Pater’s method loosens. The Leonardo entry says the drawings and faces lead to the portrait “where he gives the activity of interpretation its greatest freedom,” which marks how far the famous passage on the Mona Lisa lets its associations carry the reading. The Giorgione entry says that attribution “opens into a discussion of style as an influence,” which describes how Pater turns uncertainty over who made the pictures into a question about what their style can do, and the edition’s glossary backs this up when it defines “Giorgionesque” as an effect Pater can describe “even when attribution remains uncertain.”

There’s a fair objection to an outline built this way. A map drawn in verbs can make a writer look more methodical than he was, and several essays began as separate pieces for periodicals, with room to wander before they were collected into a book. Verbs also tell you what a critic does and leave out how his writing feels, so a reader who knew Pater only from this page would have no idea of his long, slow sentences or his habit of turning a description into a reverie. But that’s asking an outline to do the work of the essays, and the verbs have one big advantage over adjectives, which is that you can check them against the text.

What the outline gives, then, is a map of reading rather than a map of subjects, and that suits a writer whose subject is always partly the act of looking itself. Its verbs show Pater’s methods changing from essay to essay while the basic rhythm, looking first and then turning, stays the same throughout, and its few candid phrases mark where the looking loosens into interpretation. A reader who uses it before each chapter knows what to watch for, which is more than most outlines can claim.

Test your understanding

123

Question 1 of 3

What recurring structure does the author identify across Pater’s essays?

Choose one answer

Guided Inquiry

Questions for Socrates

Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.