Renaissance
A Long Throat in a Quiet Tomb
Pater singles out one feature of Medea Colleoni’s tomb. Its quiet forms make that detail seem more personal.
The Renaissance (1893)Two effigies give Pater a way to think about what makes a portrait particular. One was carved centuries after its subject died, while the other can still feel intimate even if its proportions belong to the sculptor.
Orientation
At a Glance
- One detail breaks the calmPater admires the long throat of Medea Colleoni’s effigy. The detail stands out because the tomb gives the eye so little else to follow.
- Ugo’s portrait was made centuries laterMino da Fiesole’s commission dates to 1469. The portrait had to give a convincing presence to a man who had died in 1001.
- Medea’s likeness remains an open questionGiovanni Antonio Amadeo made her tomb after her death in 1470. The long throat could reflect his style, the sitter’s proportions, or both.
- A convention can make an individual visiblePater sees these monuments as combining a shared form of repose with a distinctive detail. The detail makes the tomb feel like it belongs to someone in particular.
The Renaissance · Luca della Robbia, the tombs of Ugo and Medea · Note 123, the Tuscan middle position · Note 124, Mino’s monument to Ugo · Note 125, Medea Colleoni’s tomb · Ugo’s monument, Badia Fiorentina · Medea’s tomb, Lombardia Beni Culturali · Dante, Paradiso XVI, the great baron
Pater’s list of the noblest Tuscan tombs is mostly about calm, but one phrase in it breaks the calm on purpose. The finest works of these sculptors, he says, are “the careful sepulchral portraits of particular persons,” and he names two, the monument of Count Ugo in the Badia of Florence and that “of the youthful Medea Colleoni, with the wonderful, long throat,” in her chapel at Bergamo. Everything around that phrase speaks of repose and “a kind of sacred grace and refinement,” so the throat stands out like a single sustained note in a hushed choir, and it’s worth asking why a writer so devoted to restraint would single out one bodily detail at all.
Start with Ugo, because his portrait is a strange one. He was margrave of Tuscany, the son of the countess Willa who founded the Badia, and he died on the feast of St. Thomas in 1001, which is why Dante remembers him in the Paradiso as il gran barone (the great baron) whose name and worth the feast of Thomas renews each year. The monks commissioned Mino da Fiesole in 1469 to replace his old tomb, and the finished monument of 1481, with its life-size effigy on a sarcophagus, the Madonna and Child above and a figure of Charity, carries an inscription saying they restored a tomb worn with age. Ugo’s remains had lain until then in an ancient porphyry sarcophagus near the high altar, and Mino was carving the face of a man dead for nearly five centuries, so the portrait’s personal effect does not tell us what he looked like.
Medea is the opposite case, a death that was raw when the stone was cut. She was the daughter of the famous condottiere Bartolomeo Colleoni, she died young in 1470, and her grieving father had the Lombard sculptor Giovanni Antonio Amadeo carve her tomb for a church he’d founded at Basella, near Urgnano, where it stayed until it was moved into the Colleoni Chapel in Bergamo in 1842. She lies on a sarcophagus marked with her family’s arms, hands folded across her breast, beneath a relief of the dead Christ, and the regional heritage catalogue describes the humanist style of her tomb as rare in Lombardy.
The convention Pater uses to group the tombs is the one he describes a few lines later, a method that works by “repressing all such curves as indicate solid form, and throwing the whole into low relief.” In practice that means the body is reduced to long, calm planes, the drapery falls in broad planes, and the recumbent figure offers long lines for the eye to follow, so the whole figure reads as rest rather than as flesh. It’s a style designed to say death in general, the common sleep that waits for everybody, and on its own terms it would seem to leave very little room for any one person to show through the stone.
That’s exactly why the throat survives, because once every other form has been quieted, a single unusual proportion becomes enormously visible, the way one long held note carries through a room where everyone else has gone silent, and the eye fastens on it as the thing that makes this sleeper different from all the others. The Roman portrait busts that pile on wrinkles and warts try to capture a person by adding detail, while the Tuscan method captures a person by subtraction, letting one trait stand alone against a field of repose, and Pater’s “wonderful” is his response to how much a single detail can carry once the noise around it has been cleared away.
There’s a complication worth facing, though, because Amadeo was a Lombard who loved long, elegant proportions, so the throat Pater admires might be the sculptor’s habit rather than the girl’s anatomy, the same problem that dogs any claim that Botticelli’s women all show one model, and Ugo’s face proves that these “portraits of particular persons” could be particular without being accurate. The particularity, in other words, may belong to the art rather than the sitter, a distinctive trait the sculptor supplied so that a calm tomb would feel personal, whether or not Medea’s neck was really that long.
Even so, the effect is real, and it clarifies what Pater means by Tuscan conventionalism. He places these sculptors midway between the Greeks, who purged the individual in favor of the type, and Michelangelo, who wanted the inward history of a particular soul, and the Medea tomb shows how the middle position works in practice. The overall repose speaks the language of the type, death as calm and universal, while the one remembered detail speaks the language of the person, so the tomb says two things at once, that everyone dies and that this girl died, and the throat is where the second message gets in.
My verdict is that the long throat proves Pater’s larger point. Tuscan convention doesn’t erase the individual, it isolates and amplifies a single trait until that trait can carry a whole person, and the contrast between one personal detail and a tomb’s overall repose is the method itself rather than an exception to it. Ugo’s posthumous portrait shows that the method can even manufacture particularity where no likeness survives, and Medea’s throat shows it at its finest, which is why Pater, in the middle of praising restraint, couldn’t resist naming the one thing the restraint was built to let through.
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 3
Why does the author argue that Medea’s long throat becomes especially powerful within the tomb’s restrained style?
Guided Inquiry
Questions for Socrates
Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.
- If a portrait feels particular without being anatomically accurate, in what sense can it still represent an individual?→
- Why might restraint make a single personal feature more expressive than a portrait filled with distinctive details?→
- Does the possibility that Medea’s long throat reflects Amadeo’s style weaken the author’s interpretation, or does it reveal something important about how art creates individuality?→