Renaissance
A Life Read Like a Statue
Goethe compares the memory of a person to the presence of a work of art. Pater asks how Winckelmann’s composure can hold so much heat.
The Renaissance (1893)Pater reads Goethe’s portrait of Winckelmann alongside the letters and ambitions that make its quiet ideal harder to pin down.
Orientation
At a Glance
- Goethe’s comparisonGoethe treats the memory of a remarkable person as something a later generation can encounter like a work of art.
- Pater keeps both sides in viewThe calm figure Goethe imagines retains the color of a passionate intellectual life.
- Lava becomes a modelPater’s image of enthusiasm burning like lava makes it possible to imagine the lasting form as the product of heat.
- The letters resist a fixed poseA quarrel and the troubled tone of the correspondence keep the finished portrait from becoming too serene.
The Renaissance · Winckelmann, Goethe’s portrait and its inexhaustibility · Note 275, Goethe’s 1805 book · Winckelmann, enthusiasm burning like lava · Winckelmann, the troubled letters and the quiet History · Goethe, Winckelmann, full German text · Winkelmann und sein Jahrhundert, 1805 edition
Pater’s essay opens by pointing to “a few pages of strange pregnancy” in Goethe’s writings on art. In them Goethe “speaks of the teacher who had made his career possible, but whom he had never seen, as of an abstract type of culture, consummate, tranquil, withdrawn already into the region of ideals, yet retaining colour from the incidents of a passionate intellectual life.” Goethe’s book of 1805, Winkelmann und sein Jahrhundert, Winckelmann and His Century, gathered letters and essays around his own sketch of the man, and Pater adds that Goethe “classes him with certain works of art, possessing an inexhaustible gift of suggestion, to which criticism may return again and again with renewed freshness.”
Goethe makes the comparison himself in the opening sentence of his sketch. His sketch begins by saying that “Das Andenken merkwürdiger Menschen, so wie die Gegenwart bedeutender Kunstwerke, regt von Zeit zu Zeit den Geist der Betrachtung auf,” the memory of remarkable people, like the presence of significant works of art, stirs the spirit of contemplation from time to time, and he treats both as legacies left to every generation. Then he arranges Winckelmann’s life under headings like Antique, Pagan, Friendship and Beauty, the way you’d organize a museum catalog by themes, and he printed the letters alongside, as if laying out a sculptor’s studies beside the finished marble. The life stops being a sequence of years and becomes an object you can walk around and view from several sides.
What happens to a human life when it’s treated this way, as an object for repeated criticism? The gain is inexhaustibility, since a work of art keeps yielding new meanings to new viewers, and Winckelmann’s life has done exactly that, read by Goethe as a pagan hero, by Pater as an aesthetic saint and by later readers through the desires and friendships his letters record. The risk is freezing, because a statue doesn’t change its mind, and a life read as an object tends to lose its mess, the quarrels, the debts, the doubts and the compromises that don’t fit the pose. Celebrities suffer the same fate, turned into posters and icons whose actual days get smoothed into a single meaning.
Pater’s achievement is that he keeps both halves alive, and he does it in his very first sentence. Goethe’s Winckelmann is “consummate, tranquil, withdrawn already into the region of ideals,” which is the language of sculpture, of the calm figures in the Vatican galleries, “yet retaining colour from the incidents of a passionate intellectual life,” which is the language of painting and of biography. The word “yet” carries the whole essay, since Pater refuses to let the ideal type swallow the particular passion or the passion break up the type. In a sense the essay is itself a third viewing, Pater looking at Goethe looking at Winckelmann, the way a gallery visitor studies an engraving made from a statue.
The best image of the balance comes a few pages later, in a single startling metaphor. “The protracted longing of his youth is not a vague, romantic longing,” Pater says, because “he knows what he longs for, what he wills,” and “Within its severe limits his enthusiasm burns like lava.” Lava is the perfect substance for this portrait, since it’s fire that cools into stone, passion on its way to becoming form, and it describes a man whose fierce temperament produced an unusually calm vision of art. The heat doesn’t contradict the statue, because the statue is what the heat becomes.
Pater finds the same double nature in two other witnesses. Lavater, the Swiss pastor who claimed to read character from faces, said of Winckelmann’s portrait, “I consider ardour and indifference by no means incompatible in the same character. If ever there was a striking instance of that union, it is in the countenance before us.” That’s a man literally reading a life off a face as if it were a carved head, finding fire and coolness together in the features, and his volumes of physiognomic studies in the 1770s were full of engraved heads read line by line in just this way. Goethe supplies the career’s outline in a run of exclamations about “A lowly childhood,” then “insufficient instruction in youth,” and then “the burden of school-keeping,” until Winckelmann “appears before us consummate and entire, complete in the ancient sense,” which is the moment when the life finally hardens into its classical shape.
Pater also adds pressure from the other side, so the portrait never settles too comfortably. Within a few pages he brings in the friendships with young men, one of which “ends noisily in a burst of angry fire,” and he admits that Winckelmann’s “perfection is a narrow perfection” and that his letters have a “troubled colouring.” This is where Pater’s essay goes beyond Goethe’s, because Goethe’s sketch gives particular weight to the coherence of Winckelmann’s character, while Pater, writing in 1867 at the start of his own career, lets the troubled letters stand beside the tranquil ideal and keeps reminding us that the calm was hard won.
My verdict is that reading a life like a work of art is legitimate as long as the work in question is understood to contain its own energy, the way a great statue holds the tension of a body in motion even while standing still. Goethe’s comparison helps explain why later readers have kept returning to Winckelmann, and Pater’s contribution is to insist that the ideal type and the particular passion explain each other rather than compete. The lava image says it best, since the enthusiasm that burned is the same substance as the form that lasted, and that’s why the life still rewards a critic who returns to it again and again.
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 3
How does Goethe’s thematic arrangement of Winckelmann’s life shape the reader’s understanding of it?
Guided Inquiry
Questions for Socrates
Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.
- When does treating a life as a work of art deepen understanding, and when might it distort or oversimplify that life?→
- How does the article’s contrast between fire and stone change your understanding of the relationship between passion and self-discipline?→
- If Pater is viewing Goethe’s view of Winckelmann, how might each additional layer of interpretation both reveal and conceal the original person?→