Renaissance
A Judgment That Starts in the Graveyard
The dead recover their bodies at the lower left of Michelangelo’s altar wall. Pater follows their ascent to ask where the whole scene gets its movement.
The Renaissance (1893)The Last Judgment shows souls saved and damned. Pater starts a step earlier, with the moment bodies rise from the ground and give the picture its upward motion.
Orientation
At a Glance
- Look to the lower leftThe dead begin to recover their bodies while trumpeting angels wake them. Pater starts his reading where flesh is coming back to life.
- The wall also shows a judgmentChrist occupies the center. Bodies rise on the left and the damned are dragged down on the right, where Charon and Minos recall Dante.
- Pater sees a pattern from the ceilingAdam’s hand barely rises toward its maker. On the altar wall, the same passage from stillness to movement plays out across a crowd.
- The beginning of the movement changes the readingResurrection makes judgment possible in the scene. For Pater, it also gives the eye a direction to follow through the whole wall.
The Renaissance · The Poetry of Michelangelo, pp. 54–55, resurrection and the altar wall · The Poetry of Michelangelo, note 137
Walk into the Sistine Chapel and turn toward the altar, and the altar wall is crowded with bodies, painted between 1536 and 1541. Most visitors go hunting for the damned, for Charon swinging his oar at the souls in his boat, or for the donkey-eared Minos with a snake coiled around him. According to Vasari, Michelangelo gave Minos the likeness of Biagio da Cesena, the papal master of ceremonies who objected to the nudity. Pater looks at the opposite corner and announces that “Not the Judgment but the Resurrection is the real subject of his last work in the Sistine Chapel,” which on first hearing is a bit like reviewing Jaws and calling it a film about beach tourism.
The corner he means is the lower left, where the dead climb out of the earth. Some are still skeletons, some are putting their flesh back on, some are being hauled up by angels while others help each other out of the ground, and near them angels sound the trumpets that wake the dead. It’s the part of the wall where life comes back into bodies, and that’s the action Pater has been tracking through the entire essay, since he calls the creation of life, “life coming always as relief or recovery,” the thing that is “in various ways the motive of all his work.” Read that way, the Last Judgment is one more Creation of Adam, staged for the whole human race at once.
The other side has an obvious case, and the edition’s own note makes it. The wall is called the Last Judgment for good reasons, because Christ stands at the center with his arm raised and his face turned toward the damned, the saved rise on the left while the damned are dragged down on the right, angels hold up books recording who goes where, and Charon and Minos come straight out of Dante’s Inferno, his journey through Hell. Halfway down the right side a man covers half his face with his hand as demons pull him under, and anyone who has seen him doesn’t forget him. Calling all this a resurrection scene can look like reading half a sentence and declaring that you’ve understood the paragraph.
The history of the commission brings the two subjects together. Clement VII called Michelangelo back to the chapel in 1533, and the project continued under Paul III. The Met’s account connects the unusual prominence of the nude body with the Christian doctrine of the Resurrection of the Dead. Michelangelo was sixty-one when he started painting, nearly a quarter century after finishing the ceiling overhead, so the old man who covered this wall with the dead climbing out of the ground was coming back to the room where he had painted the first man lifting himself off a hillside.
Then there’s the way the wall moves, which is where Pater’s instinct really pays off. Looking at it, you feel all the groups circling Christ in one enormous rotation, rising up the left side and falling down the right, like a wheel with the Judge at its hub, and a wheel has to start turning somewhere. On this wall the motion begins in the lower left, where bodies leave the ground and start upward, so the resurrection isn’t one episode among many but the engine that feeds the whole circuit. Without the rising, there’s nobody to judge, nobody to save, and nobody for Charon to ferry, so Pater’s claim makes structural sense even before you agree with its emphasis.
The question underneath is whether a visual movement can outrank a title and an iconography in telling you what a picture is about. A title names the event while leaving open how the painter has directed the eye through it. Movement, by contrast, is the thing your body actually experiences in front of a wall this size, the direction your eyes keep being pulled, and a critic who describes that experience is describing something real that a catalog label may miss.
Still, iconography isn’t a label stuck on afterward, because the damned are painted right there in the plaster, and Michelangelo spent as much invention on their terror as on the rising bodies. Christian doctrine also refuses Pater’s either-or, since the dead are raised in order to be judged, so the resurrection and the Judgment are two moments of one event. Michelangelo borrowed Charon and Minos from Dante precisely to make the punishment vivid, and nobody paints a ferryman beating souls out of his boat with an oar unless the verdict matters.
So my verdict is that Pater is right about the subject in the sense that matters to someone standing in the chapel and wrong only if “subject” means the doctrine on the wall. The resurrection is the source of the motion, the corner where Michelangelo’s peculiar genius for life arriving in flesh is most fully at work, and the subject gives Michelangelo a reason to show so many bodies in the act of taking on life. A visual movement can’t delete the damned, but it can decide where meaning starts, and on this wall it starts in the graveyard.
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 3
Why does the author call the resurrection the “engine” of the wall’s composition?
Guided Inquiry
Questions for Socrates
Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.
- When interpreting a work of art, under what conditions should the viewer’s experience of movement outweigh its traditional title or iconography?→
- Does describing the resurrection as the source of the wall’s motion illuminate the damned figures, or risk minimizing their importance? Why?→
- If resurrection and judgment are two moments of one event, what is gained—and what is lost—by insisting that one is the painting’s “real subject”?→