Renaissance

A Guest Who Built the House

Pater imagines Michelangelo finding the peace of a visitor in Rome. His work on Saint Peter’s and his poem to Vasari show a man with a stake in the place.

The late Michelangelo could be uneasy with church authorities while remaining devoted to sacred work. His unfinished Pietà and the sonnet he sent Vasari bring the difference into focus.

Orientation

At a Glance

  • Pater’s traveler finds comfort in distanceThe late artist is like a visitor in a beautiful city whose affairs do not concern him. Pater uses that distance to explain how the Roman Church could still console him.
  • Michelangelo helped build the placePaul III put him in charge of Saint Peter’s in 1547. His sustained work there makes it difficult to imagine him as a visitor with nothing at stake.
  • The late art still returns to Christ’s bodyMichelangelo worked on the Rondanini Pietà near the end of his life. In the sonnet sent to Vasari, he imagines divine love opening its arms on the cross.
  • Belonging and dissent can coexistThe pressures on Catholic reformers give Pater’s account of estrangement some weight. The architecture, sculpture and verse show how much Michelangelo still had to do with the Church.

You probably know the feeling Pater is describing, a night in some old cathedral town you’ll leave in the morning, with the bells going and the stone glowing and a peace that comes precisely from not belonging there. Pater says the Roman Church worked on the aged Michelangelo like that, leaving him “consoled and tranquillised, as a traveller might be, resting for one evening in a strange city, by its stately aspect and the sentiment of its many fortunes, just because with those fortunes he has nothing to do.” The Church, he says, “had passed beyond him, and he was a stranger to it,” fixing itself in “a frozen orthodoxy,” while Michelangelo had “long since fallen back on that divine ideal, which above the wear and tear of creeds has been forming itself for ages as the possession of nobler souls.”

The case for Pater’s picture is serious, and it should be heard first. The church of Michelangelo’s last years was hard on the people he’d loved most, since Colonna’s reforming friends fell under suspicion, Pope Paul IV’s Inquisition jailed Cardinal Giovanni Morone in 1557, and after Michelangelo’s death another member of that circle, Pietro Carnesecchi, was executed in 1567. The Council of Trent issued its rules on sacred images at the end of 1563, and Daniele da Volterra later began adding draperies to figures in the Last Judgment, after Michelangelo’s death. Pater also mentions early members of Filippo Neri’s Oratory, which was only formally approved in 1575, without saying which of them he means. If you want to call Michelangelo a stranger to that institution, you have evidence.

But a guest with nothing to do with the city’s fortunes? In 1547 Pope Paul III put him in charge of Saint Peter’s. Michelangelo kept working on the project under successive popes and described the responsibility as a service to God. Pater actually knows this, because in the same paragraph he describes the Church looking “stronger than ever” in “the vast world’s cathedral which his skill had helped to raise for it.” The man drawing the dome isn’t a tourist admiring it, and you don’t usually describe the person who designed the hotel as a visitor passing through for the night.

The building and the carving didn’t stop there either. In 1561 he began adapting part of the Baths of Diocletian for the church of Santa Maria degli Angeli at the request of Pope Pius IV, and in his own workshop he kept carving the dead Christ held by his mother, ending with the Rondanini Pietà, which he was still working on in his final days. The Pietà gave his late work a specifically Christian subject. He kept returning to the body of Christ and the grief of Mary well past eighty.

His own words, set down in verse, settle the question of tone. In 1554 he sent Vasari a sonnet that begins “Giunto è già ’l corso della vita mia” (the course of my life has already reached its end), picturing his life as a fragile boat on a stormy sea reaching the common harbor where everyone must give an account of their deeds. He admits that the “affettüosa fantasia / che l’arte mi fece idol e monarca” (the fond fantasy that made art my idol and my king) was full of error, and he ends with “Né pinger né scolpir fie più che quieti / l’anima, volta a quell’amor divino / c’aperse, a prender noi, ’n croce le braccia,” which means neither painting nor sculpture will quiet the soul any longer, turned now to that divine love which opened its arms on the cross to take us in.

That last image is the opposite of Pater’s traveller. The traveller is soothed by a stately view and by having nothing at stake, and Michelangelo’s comfort comes from arms opened on a cross to gather him in, which is about as close and personal as consolation can get. Pater’s image offers the consolation of distance, and the poem chooses the consolation of belonging without a moment’s hesitation. Pater can point to reasons for unease with church authorities. The evidence of the work and the sonnet shows that Michelangelo’s building, carving and prayer continued.

So whose traveller is this, if he isn’t Michelangelo? He fits a certain kind of Victorian visitor to Rome a lot better than he fits Michelangelo, somebody who loves the incense and the music and the old stones while doubting the creed, and who finds the whole spectacle “theatrical in its life, theatrical in its art, theatrical even in its devotion,” to borrow Pater’s own sneer. That figure existed, and Pater knew him well, which may be why the simile is so tender. But a man who calls a ghost a revenant (literally, one who comes back), as Pater does here, ought to notice when the ghost he’s describing is partly his own reflection.

Can a church console an artist who feels like its guest? Sometimes it can, and the traveller’s evening peace is real enough. Michelangelo, though, was never a guest in that house. He was more like a member of the household who fought with its management, saw its harshness fall on people in his circle, kept working on its buildings, and found his comfort in the figure at its center rather than in its stately front. Pater’s image tells you about his own distance from Rome, and the old man there was inside, uneasy, devout and still building.

Test your understanding

123

Question 1 of 3

What is the article’s central contrast between Pater’s traveller image and Michelangelo’s sonnet?

Choose one answer

Guided Inquiry

Questions for Socrates

Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.