Renaissance

A Great Poet Can Still Write Filler

Wordsworth’s gift can shape an entire poem or shine through a few lines. Pater shows how to tell the difference.

Pater follows Wordsworth’s feeling for life in nature through a body of uneven verse. A leech-gatherer who looks like a boulder helps explain how a poem can be deeply distinctive and still give a parodist something to work with.

Orientation

At a Glance

  • A gift can reach unevenlyPater says Wordsworth’s imagination transforms some poems throughout and leaves a fine crystal here or there in others. A single passage can show a poet’s distinctive gift.
  • The old man and the moorWordsworth compares the leech-gatherer to a boulder and then to a sea creature. Those comparisons give the man a place in the landscape and make the landscape seem alive.
  • A whole poem can still have faultsCarroll makes comedy out of the narrator’s repeated questioning, and Coleridge objects to part of the Immortality Ode. Their objections leave room for Pater’s claim about what holds each poem together.
  • Ask what the poem carriesPater wants the critic to say where Wordsworth’s sense of life in nature enters the verse and how far it reaches. Naming that quality gives other readers something to look for.

Every great artist has filler, the album with two tracks you always skip, the novelist whose middle books nobody rereads, and most of us deal with it by quietly pretending it isn’t there. Pater refuses to pretend, saying that “few artists, not Goethe or Byron even, work quite cleanly, casting off all débris,” where the French word means scraps, and then he picks the hardest case available, William Wordsworth, one of the most revered English poets of the century, and says flatly that in his “great mass of verse” there is a good deal that could be forgotten. It’s a bold thing to say about a poet that Victorian readers treated almost as a sage, and what makes it more than a put-down is the image Pater uses to explain how the good and the forgettable can sit in the same body of work.

The image he reaches for is heat, “the heat of his genius, entering into the substance of his work,” which “has crystallised a part, but only a part, of it.” Sometimes that heat is strong enough to be found “fusing and transforming entire compositions,” and sometimes, “as if at random,” it ends up “depositing a fine crystal here or there, in a matter it does not wholly search through and transmute.” Think of how rock behaves under heat and pressure, where sometimes a whole formation is changed through and through, and sometimes you crack open an ordinary grey stone and find a pocket of crystal inside. The power is the same in both cases, and what changes is how far it reached into the material.

That picture lets Pater separate two things that critics usually blur, an author’s distinctive power and the uneven success of his work. Most of us judge a writer either by his average or by his best, and both of those are measures of output. Pater measures something else, the presence of one faculty and how far it gets into the verse, and he names Wordsworth’s faculty with real precision, “that strange, mystical sense of a life in natural things, and of man’s life as a part of nature.” Then he defines the critic’s job in the same terms, to follow that power through the work and “to mark the degree in which it penetrates his verse,” so the question about any poem becomes how deep the heat went, not how good the poem is overall.

Pater gives two poems as examples of the heat working all the way through, and they make a good test. The first is “Resolution and Independence,” in which a troubled speaker walking on a moor meets an old leech-gatherer, and the poem’s most famous move is to turn that old man into part of the landscape, comparing him to a boulder in the lines “As a huge stone is sometimes seen to lie / Couched on the bald top of an eminence,” and then to a sea-beast that has crawled out onto a ledge to sun itself. If you wanted a picture of man’s life as a part of nature, you could hardly do better than a man who looks like a rock that might be alive, so the poem really does seem soaked in the faculty Pater named.

It’s also a poem people have laughed at, since shortly before Pater’s Preface, Lewis Carroll gave the White Knight a song in Through the Looking-Glass about an aged man sitting on a gate who gets asked over and over how he makes his living, a direct send-up of Wordsworth’s narrator pestering the old man with the same question. So a poem Pater calls wholly fused had a repeated exchange that Carroll could turn to comic effect, and that tells you what “fusing” has to mean. It can’t mean that every line is perfect, so it has to mean that the faculty runs all the way through, and Carroll’s parody of the repeated question leaves the stone and sea-beast comparisons doing their work.

The second example confirms the point, and Pater calls it the “Ode on the Recollections of Childhood,” while the edition’s note gives its usual title, the Immortality Ode, whose opening contrasts the remembered radiance of ordinary things with the way they look now. This is about as fused as English poetry gets, and yet Coleridge, Wordsworth’s closest collaborator, spent pages of chapter 22 of his Biographia Literaria objecting to the stanza that hails a six-year-old as a mighty prophet and seer, which he found absurdly inflated. If even the poems Pater picks as his clearest cases contain lines that serious readers winced at, then his distinction must be about penetration and not polish, and I think that’s the right place to draw it.

The distinction matters because it changes how you read anyone uneven, which is to say almost everyone. It frees you to love an artist without defending every page, and it tells you how to read the rest, looking for the crystals in the grey stone instead of either throwing the stone away or pretending it sparkles. Matthew Arnold took a related approach in his 1879 selection of Wordsworth, and Pater himself published “On Wordsworth” the year after the Preface. The same logic works for a songwriter whose albums are patchy but whose one great song shows what the whole catalogue was reaching for.

So the heat-and-crystal image does what it promises, separating an author’s power from his success rate by measuring how far the power penetrates rather than how good the average poem is. The risk is that it can excuse anything, since you can always claim the crystal is in there somewhere, and the only guard against that is naming the faculty precisely enough that others can check whether a given poem has it, which Pater does for Wordsworth in one exact phrase. Tested on his own examples, the idea holds up nicely, because it predicts what we actually find, two poems shot through with Wordsworth’s strange sense of nature that still have lines you’d cut if you were his editor.

Test your understanding

123

Question 1 of 3

What does Pater’s heat-and-crystal image primarily distinguish?

Choose one answer

Guided Inquiry

Questions for Socrates

Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.