Renaissance

A Fruit That Grows on the Branch

Pater sets aside the fruit of experience, then asks passion for a fruit of its own. The question is whether a fuller awareness belongs to the experience itself.

An outward reward is different from the pleasure or intensity an activity has while it is happening. Pater’s language leaves open what happens when the person begins looking for that intensity.

Orientation

At a Glance

  • The first fruitPater puts aside the reward that can be carried away from an experience and asks what the experience is worth while it is happening.
  • The second fruitThe closing paragraph calls a quickened consciousness the fruit of passion, leaving the reader to decide whether it is part of the experience or its payoff.
  • Aristotle’s comparisonAristotle likens pleasure to the bloom of youth, giving the article a way to imagine a quality that accompanies an activity.
  • What changes in 1893Pater replaces several named kinds of passion with a broader phrase that makes explicit room for disinterested activity.

The sentence is short and it sounds like a manifesto. “Not the fruit of experience, but experience itself, is the end.” The edition’s note explains that “fruit” here means the result or reward that survives an activity, the lesson learned, the moral drawn, the credential earned, the way a trip abroad is sometimes justified by the line it adds to a résumé. Pater is refusing that kind of accounting, and he wants the trip to be worth taking for what it is while it happens. The sentence takes the measure of the activity from the experience a person actually has. Then, near the end of the essay, he says that great passions give us a quickened sense of life, and adds, “Only be sure it is passion,” and that it “does yield you this fruit of a quickened, multiplied consciousness.”

So the fruit he threw out the front door seems to come back in through the kitchen. There are two ways to read the return, and they lead to very different essays. On the generous reading, the two fruits are different things, the first an outward reward that outlasts the activity and the second a quality inside the activity itself, so there’s no contradiction at all. On the suspicious reading, the second fruit is still a product, a result that justifies the passion, and Pater’s test, “be sure it is passion” because it yields intensity, makes intensity the real end and passion merely the means.

The generous reading has an ancient ally, and he got there first. In the Nicomachean Ethics, Aristotle says pleasure completes an activity as an end that comes with it, “as the bloom of youth does on those in the flower of their age.” The bloom isn’t a separate result you can carry off, it’s the glow on the activity while the activity is going well. Pater’s “quickened, multiplied consciousness” can be read the same way, as the bloom on a passion, present in it and not left over after it.

That reading also fits Pater’s verb better than it first appears. Fruit “yielded” in the first sense is picked and carried away to market, while a quickened consciousness can’t be stored or taken home, since it exists only while you’re living through the passion that quickens it. Pater even tells you where to look for it, since art “comes to you proposing frankly to give nothing but the highest quality to your moments as they pass, and simply for those moments’ sake.” Quality is a property of the moment, so the second fruit grows on the branch and stays there.

But the suspicious reading isn’t easy to dismiss, and the first edition makes it sharper. In 1873 Pater’s examples of passions that give the quickened sense of life were “ecstasy and sorrow of love, political or religious enthusiasm, or the” enthusiasm of humanity, a phrase John Robert Seeley uses in Ecce Homo for the love of humankind he sees Christ trying to kindle. Put a love of humanity on a list of things worth having because they quicken your consciousness, and the problem is obvious. A love of humanity valued for what it does to the lover’s pulse rate has turned humanity into a means, which is close to the opposite of what Seeley meant.

The test Pater proposes, checking whether a passion yields its fruit, also points attention in the wrong direction. Passion, in the ordinary sense, is absorbed in its object, the beloved or the cause or the music, and the moment you start checking how intense the experience is, you’ve stepped out of it into a kind of inspection. Aristotle’s bloom avoids this, because the bloom comes when you attend to the activity and its object, not to the bloom, the way a joke stops being funny the instant you analyze whether you’re laughing enough, and lovers who keep asking whether they’re in love enough are often the first to fall out of it. Pater’s phrasing, “Only be sure,” asks for exactly the kind of self-checking that kills the thing it’s checking for.

The 1893 wording gives the reader more room to ask whether the pressure is unavoidable. He replaced the named enthusiasms with “the various forms of enthusiastic activity, disinterested or otherwise, which come naturally to many of us,” and the word “disinterested” is the interesting addition, since a disinterested enthusiasm is precisely one that isn’t pursued for what it yields to the enthusiast. By naming it, Pater allows an enthusiasm to be absorbed in its object and still give a person a fuller awareness of the moment.

The two uses of fruit can be reconciled, and the reconciliation is real. The first is an outward reward that survives the activity, while the second is a quality inside the activity, the bloom on the branch, and read that way, experience is its own end and the quickened consciousness is simply what experience feels like when it goes well. The tension Pater leaves comes from the test rather than the terms, since asking a passion to prove itself by its intensity makes intensity the master, and the best answer to that problem is Aristotle’s, attend to the thing you love and let the bloom take care of itself.

Test your understanding

123

Question 1 of 3

How does the article’s generous reading reconcile Pater’s rejection of the “fruit of experience” with his praise of a “quickened, multiplied consciousness”?

Choose one answer

Guided Inquiry

Questions for Socrates

Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.