Renaissance

A Flame That Holds Its Shape

The famous gem-like flame gathers up two earlier images of fire. Its hardness asks what it takes to keep attention steady while experience changes.

The body’s flame is always being renewed and the mind’s flame is eager. The last flame gives that change a shape that can be held.

Orientation

At a Glance

  • What the word this recallsThe famous line points back to the bodily and mental flames already at work in the essay.
  • A body continually renewedPater compares the body to a form held briefly together by forces that keep arriving and passing away.
  • What the gem addsThe comparison with a faceted stone lets the essay imagine a brilliance with enough definition to distinguish one impression from another.
  • How to maintain ecstasyPater puts the effort of holding an experience beside the intensity of being carried out of ordinary attention.

Pater’s most familiar sentence begins with a backward glance. “To burn always with this hard, gem-like flame, to maintain this ecstasy, is success in life.” It is easy to quote by itself and miss the earlier passages it takes up. But look at the word “this,” which points backward, since you can only speak of this particular flame when a flame has already been introduced. The gem-like flame is the same fire the essay has been tending for two pages, now described as it ought to burn.

The first flame belongs to the body, and it shows up the moment the chemistry is done, when Pater says that “This at least of flame-like our life has, that it is but the concurrence, renewed from moment to moment, of forces parting sooner or later on their ways.” A flame is the perfect image of that kind of life, since it looks like a steady thing while it’s really a process, fuel and air arriving and burning and leaving, so the shape is renewed every instant from new material. The second flame is the mind’s, when Pater turns inward and says that “the whirlpool is still more rapid, the flame more eager and devouring.” Now the fire has appetite, it consumes faster, and it’s hungrier for whatever it can catch.

So the final flame inherits two things from the flames that came before it. From the body it keeps renewal, the fact that it exists only by being fed from moment to moment, and from the mind it keeps eagerness, the devouring speed of attention. The note to the famous sentence describes it as concentrating two qualities Pater has just set in motion, “the brilliance of an intense impression and the constant change of the forces sustaining it.” Neither inherited quality is stable, since renewal means the flame is always being rebuilt and eagerness means it’s always reaching for more fuel, so whatever steadiness the final image has must be won against the nature of fire itself. What the gem adds is everything a natural flame lacks, edge and steadiness and a kind of brilliance that seems to come from inside.

Here the jewelers can help, because they have a word for exactly this. In the trade, the flashes of spectral colour in a diamond are called its fire. They come from the way the stone disperses light into colours. They depend on the cut, because each facet catches and returns light at its own angle, so a stone shows its fire only when it has been shaped with many faces. A gem-like flame, then, is a fire that has acquired facets, and that’s the deepest sense of the image, since the essay’s whole ethic is discrimination, catching a different light off each face of experience instead of a single undifferentiated glow.

The hardness is what adds the difficulty, and it’s easy to miss. Any flame flickers, and that’s the easy part, since flicker is what fire does when you leave it alone. If you’ve ever adjusted a lab burner, you know the moment when the lazy, wavering yellow flame snaps into a tight blue cone with sharp edges, steady and much hotter, and you know it only happens when the air and fuel are balanced just right. A hard flame is a controlled flame, and to “burn always” in that way means holding attention steady without letting it go slack or wild, which takes far more effort than simply feeling things intensely.

The second clause makes the same demand in different words. Ecstasy suggests being carried out of one’s ordinary state, while maintaining something takes continuing effort. To maintain an ecstasy is to keep a hand on something that by its nature takes you out of yourself, and the paradox is the point. The two clauses of the sentence say the same thing twice, once as an image and once as a paradox, which is a good sign that Pater means it. Pater isn’t asking for occasional peaks, he’s asking for a sustained intensity that stays shaped, the way a great player’s concentration in a long match is both fierce and calm.

There’s a reading of the image that makes it precious and a little silly, as if Pater wanted life to be a jewel box, all glitter and no use, and some of his critics read it that way. I think the hardness argues against that reading rather than for it. The hardness of the gem offers a contrast to the movement Pater has been describing, set against a world where “all melts under our feet,” and pairing it with a flame keeps each half honest, so that the flame stops being chaos and the gem stops being dead. In 1873 the phrase was “hard gem-like flame,” while the comma in the 1893 text makes it easier to hear two distinct qualities, hardness and brilliance.

The hard, gem-like flame is a summary image, and it earns its fame by gathering up the essay rather than escaping it. It keeps the body’s renewal and the mind’s eagerness, adds the faceted fire that stands for discrimination, and asks for steadiness, which is why the sentence is harder to live than it is to quote. Pater’s success in life turns out to be a matter of control as much as passion, a fire that burns hot enough to see by and steady enough to keep its shape.

Test your understanding

123

Question 1 of 3

Why does the article emphasize the word “this” in Pater’s famous sentence?

Choose one answer

Guided Inquiry

Questions for Socrates

Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.