Renaissance

A Fair Hearing for Every Age

Pater takes from Blake the idea that genius can appear in any age. His own question is how a great artist gives an age’s tastes and tensions form.

Pater can prize fifteenth-century Italy and still find excellence in medieval French stories or in Winckelmann. His Preface separates the attention every period deserves from the judgments a critic makes after reading and looking.

Orientation

At a Glance

  • Give each period a hearingPater starts from the idea that every period and school can produce excellent work. A critic still has to look closely enough to distinguish the work that deserves attention.
  • Blake’s quarrel with ReynoldsBlake points to Gothic figures and buildings in his annotations to Reynolds. For him, genius can appear in periods that critics dismiss as dark.
  • Genius above or within an agePater borrows Blake’s phrase about genius rising above its age. He also asks in whom the spirit of an age finds itself, a question that makes an artist a witness to their own time.
  • Some conditions help work flourishPater admires fifteenth-century Italy for the exchanges among artists, thinkers, and people of action. Those exchanges help explain why a period flourishes without deciding where else beauty can appear.

The passage sets two ideas side by side and dares you to notice the tension. “To him all periods, types, schools of taste, are in themselves equal,” Pater says of his critic, and then, “In all ages there have been some excellent workmen, and some excellent work done.” He closes by quoting William Blake, that “the ages are all equal,” but that “genius is always above its age.” In his annotations to Sir Joshua Reynolds’s Discourses, Blake points to Gothic figures and buildings as he rejects the language of dark ages. Pater’s puzzle is how a critic can give every school a fair hearing and still make judgments about excellence.

The equality is a rule for where a critic is willing to look. Pater gives whole chapters to two little tales from medieval France and to an eighteenth-century German scholar. He says he chose Amis and Amile and Aucassin and Nicolette because they help give the book unity, linking an early French Renaissance with its later flowering in French poetry. Winckelmann takes his place for a different reason. Pater thinks this scholar’s enthusiasm for Greece makes him a late heir to Renaissance humanism.

That rule had a target in 1873, because a lot of Victorian criticism had favorite ages and dark ages. John Ruskin’s The Stones of Venice treats the rise of Renaissance architecture as part of Venice’s decline, though Ruskin also traces that decline to changes within Gothic building itself. Pater takes a different view of what can coexist within one period, and in the same Preface he goes after the habit of setting religious art against the Renaissance, talking about what “as Christian art, is often falsely opposed to the Renaissance.” Saying all ages are equal is his way of declaring that no period gets thrown out before the critic has looked at it.

Look closely at how Pater uses Blake, though, because he bends him. Blake says genius is “above its age,” which pictures the genius standing on top of his time and looking down, ahead of it and against it. Pater’s own question points the other way, since he asks in whom the stir and sentiment of a period found itself, which pictures the genius as the place where an age comes to a point, its spirit concentrated in one person rather than escaped from. The two ideas emphasize different things. Blake’s remark directs attention to what a genius can do regardless of the age. Pater also asks what a genius can show us about the age itself.

The book gives us examples of both kinds. His Leonardo is Blake’s kind of genius, a man who seemed to his contemporaries “the possessor of some unsanctified and secret wisdom” and seemed to later writers like Michelet “to have anticipated modern ideas,” standing above and ahead of his century. His Botticelli and his Pico are Pater’s kind, people whose work holds the mixed feelings of their moment, the pagan and the Christian pulling at each other in a single face or a single life. And Winckelmann is a third case, an eighteenth-century man who, the Preface says, belongs in spirit to an earlier age.

Then there’s the question of historical circumstances, which Pater seems to answer against himself a page later. He calls Italy’s fifteenth century “that solemn fifteenth century which can hardly be studied too much” and describes it as one of the happier eras when artists, philosophers and men of action shared their thoughts and lifted each other’s work. That sounds like exactly the favored age Blake was arguing against. The way out is to read “in themselves equal” as equal in their claim on our attention and in the possibility of excellence, while some ages give their talents more chances to learn from one another.

There’s a real risk in the word “equal,” and it’s worth naming. Taken loosely it becomes a refusal to judge, the shrug that says every period and every taste is as good as every other, and Pater could be read that way by anyone who wanted an excuse not to choose. But he doesn’t behave like a relativist at all. He ranks constantly within periods, calling Botticelli “a secondary painter” even while loving him, and saying of Wordsworth’s great mass of verse that “there is much which might well be forgotten,” which is not how a relativist talks. The equality he grants is a starting rule and never a final verdict, and the book is full of verdicts.

So Pater’s position holds together once you see what each half is doing. Equality is a rule of method, so that no age is dismissed in advance, and inequality is a result, so that some works and people come out ahead once you’ve looked. Historical circumstances can explain why certain kinds of work flourish in particular periods. That rule is also what gives the book its shape, since a volume that runs from a medieval song-story to an eighteenth-century scholar only makes sense if no period is turned away at the door. And I think his quiet revision of Blake is an improvement, at least for a historian, since a genius who concentrates the tastes and tensions of an age gives a historian a way to read it.

Test your understanding

123

Question 1 of 3

How does the article ultimately reconcile Pater’s claim that all ages are equal with his repeated judgments of artistic excellence?

Choose one answer

Guided Inquiry

Questions for Socrates

Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.