Philosophy

A Dream From the Gate of Horn or Ivory

Before Socrates pictures a city run by real experts, he calls the picture a dream. Penelope’s two gates give us a way to read his warning.

The gates of horn and ivory frame Socrates’ vision of expert rule as something worth examining before putting faith in it.

Orientation

At a Glance

  • Socrates announces a dreamHe offers a city where impostors are found out and genuine experts do the work. He asks his listeners to consider which kind of dream it might be.
  • Penelope doubts her own dreamThe disguised Odysseus hears her describe an eagle, her geese, and the gates of horn and ivory. The scene gives a reader reason to take the dream more seriously than she does.
  • Expertise leaves a question openSocrates grants that the people in his dream would act knowledgeably. He still asks whether that would make them happy.
  • Virgil makes the gate puzzling againAnchises sends Aeneas and the Sibyl through the ivory gate after Aeneas sees Rome’s future. The choice makes readers think again about the vision they just heard.

Charmides 171d–172a, 172e–173c, 173c–d · Homer, Odyssey 19.535–543, 19.544–567 · Theaetetus 201d–202c · Francis Bacon The New Atlantis · Xenophon, Hellenica 2.4.19 · Virgil, Aeneid 6.893–898

Socrates has just said something strange has come to light, and he hesitates before saying what. “I think I’m talking nonsense,” he admits, then adds, “All the same, one must look into what comes to light and not let it go by at random, if one cares for oneself even a little.” Critias agrees, and Socrates begins, “Hear my dream, then,” adding, “whether it has come through horn or through ivory.” What follows is the most attractive picture in the dialogue, a world where temperance rules completely and no impostor can fool anyone, and it is wrapped from the first word in uncertainty about whether it can be trusted. The hesitation gives us a reason to pay attention to what the picture can show and where it may disappoint.

The phrase recalls the Odyssey. Penelope tells a disguised stranger, who is really Odysseus, about a dream in which an eagle kills the twenty geese she keeps. The eagle explains that the geese are her suitors and he is her husband. Penelope says dreams come through two gates, horn for dreams that come true and ivory for dreams that deceive. The Greek words for the materials sound like words used for what the dreams do. Penelope doubts her dream has come through the true gate. A reader knows her husband is already there listening to her doubt it.

A dream can be worth examining before anyone knows whether to trust it. In the Theaetetus, Socrates also introduces a possible account of knowledge as a dream for a dream, then examines it with his companions. In the Charmides, the Homeric frame lets us take the picture of the city seriously and ask what would have to be true for it to come through the gate of horn.

The picture itself is easy to like. Every pilot is genuine, every doctor competent, and even the prophets honest. Francis Bacon’s New Atlantis gives an island a college devoted to understanding nature and using what it learns. Bacon’s imagined institution is different from Socrates’ arrangement, but it’s easy to see the appeal the two share. A society can do a great deal when it has people who really know their work.

The ivory gate warns us about what the dream leaves out. It promises a world without error, but it never says who decides what the experts should aim at, and Socrates exposes that gap at once, granting the dream everything it offers and still refusing to grant that its citizens would do well and be happy. A society that eliminated every impostor would still need someone who knew what was worth doing, and the dream, for all its appeal, has no place for that person, which is exactly where it starts to sound like ivory. The impostors the dream removes are all experts in means, pilots, doctors, generals and prophets, and nobody in the dream is ever checked for knowledge of ends.

There’s also a darker possibility for readers who know what happened later. Earlier, Socrates imagined himself and his companion among people ruling without error. His companion is Critias, whom Xenophon counts among the Thirty. That later history gives a reader reason to hear the confidence of the earlier proposal with unease. It leaves open what Socrates and Critias think they can establish in this conversation.

Virgil took up the two gates centuries later. After Aeneas has seen a vision of Rome’s future, Anchises sends him and the Sibyl back through the ivory gate. The gate belongs to false dreams. The poem leaves readers to ask what to make of its choice. That lingering question is a good companion to the one Socrates raises before describing his city of experts.

My verdict is that the two gates tell us how to hold the dream. Penelope can doubt a dream and have good reason to think about what it shows her. Socrates can value genuine expertise and still ask what knowledge the expert city needs before it can make good use of its skills.

Test your understanding

123

Question 1 of 3

What does the article suggest is the main value of framing Socrates’ ideal city as a dream that may have come through either gate?

Choose one answer

Guided Inquiry

Questions for Socrates

Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.