Renaissance

A Crowd That Never Stood in One Place

Michelet imagines Abelard’s students on a Paris hillside with centuries of consequences standing among them.

Pater borrows a scene from Michelet in which one medieval school seems to contain its entire future. The two writers look at the same imagined crowd and see different destinations for its intellectual freedom.

Orientation

At a Glance

  • A school and a towerPater places a later tower near Abelard’s school on the hill of Sainte-Geneviève. Michelet identifies the tower as the Tour de Clovis and dates its base earlier than Abelard’s teaching.
  • The crowd grows across centuriesMichelet begins with listeners and adds the offices and movements he sees following from them. Scholastic philosophy and the Renaissance enter the picture alongside people.
  • Two writers see different futuresMichelet’s list ends with Arnold of Brescia and revolution. Pater carries the school’s spirit toward the literature of Italy and an interest in passion and physical beauty.
  • An image of influencePater says Michelet sees the gathering in thought. The scene makes a claim about what follows from a school, and the reader can ask which links in that history are persuasive.

The scene starts under a tower that the two historians date differently. Pater places us “at the foot of that early Gothic tower, which the next generation raised to grace the precincts of Abelard’s school, on the ‘Mountain of Saint Geneviève,’” the hill on the Left Bank of Paris where Abelard taught crowds of students in the early twelfth century. In Michelet’s account, this is the Tour de Clovis, whose surviving base was already there when Abelard taught. The French heritage inventory dates the base to the eleventh century. The chronology differs, but both writers use the tower as a place to look back. From it Michelet imagines “a terrible assembly,” a gathering that inspires awe.

Then comes Michelet’s list, and it’s worth reading slowly because it changes kind as it goes. First there are “the hearers of Abelard,” the students who actually sat in front of him, among them the young Englishman John of Salisbury, who later wrote about hearing him on this very hill. Then there are “fifty bishops, twenty cardinals, two popes,” Michelet’s tally of the school’s later influence. A former pupil, Guido de Castello, did become Pope Celestine II. Then “the whole body of scholastic philosophy,” which is no longer a group of people at all but a centuries-long tradition, and by now the crowd has quietly turned from an audience into a historical outcome.

The list keeps climbing from there, as Michelet adds “the learned Heloïse, the teaching of languages, and the Renaissance,” and then, for his finale, Arnold of Brescia, who stands in the list for nothing less than “the revolution.” Arnold of Brescia supported Abelard and was included in the pope’s condemnation. He later supported the Roman commune against papal temporal power and was executed in 1155. But Michelet doesn’t stop at the man, since he translates him into an abstraction, and Michelet was the great historian of the French Revolution, so the last face in the crowd turns out to be his own century looking back at the twelfth and recognizing itself. It’s as if a family album ended with a photograph of the person holding the album.

That’s the key to reading the scene, which is to sort out the historical crowd from the futures. The historical scene is a school on a hill, full of ambitious young clerics, some of whom would rise very high in the Church. Everything after that, scholastic philosophy, the Renaissance and the Revolution, is a gathering of consequences, a time-lapse in which centuries stand shoulder to shoulder. It works the way an old photo of a garage band works once the members are famous, when you look at the kids in the picture and see the stadium tours, the solo careers and the whole later history of rock standing invisibly behind them. The picture is real, but nobody in it could have seen what you see when you look at it now.

Pater uses the scene to show a movement leaving home. “And so from the rooms of this shadowy house by the Seine side we see that spirit going abroad,” he writes, and the image is of something spreading outward from a single address, the canon’s house where Abelard and Heloïse fell in love, into the schools, the Church, Italy and beyond. Michelet’s crowd gives that spreading a face, or rather hundreds of faces, so Pater can show influence as a population and not just as an idea passed between books. The house itself was a private place, a canon’s home where two people fell in love over their lessons, and Pater’s point is that what began there in private didn’t stay there. A love affair and a set of lectures turned into a culture, and the crowd under the tower is Michelet’s way of picturing that turning.

Then Pater quietly changes the destination, because Michelet’s list ends in politics, with Arnold and the revolution, but Pater’s own list of the qualities that spirit carried abroad ends somewhere else entirely, in “its intimacy, its languid sweetness, its rebellion, its subtle skill in dividing the elements of human passion, its care for physical beauty, its worship of the body.” Rebellion is still there, but it sits in the middle, surrounded by sweetness, passion and the body. Michelet saw the barricades in Abelard’s school, and Pater sees a love poem and a statue, so the same crowd is marching toward two different futures depending on who’s narrating.

That difference tells you something about both historians, since Michelet was a republican who wanted the Middle Ages to prepare the Revolution, and Pater was an aesthete who wanted them to prepare the Renaissance of the senses and the arts. Each draws on the same twelfth-century school and sees in it the beginnings of what he himself loved, which is the oldest temptation in the writing of history, and also one of its pleasures. Pater is at least candid that he’s borrowing a vision, introducing Michelet as someone who “sees in thought,” not as someone reporting what happened. And the Preface has already confessed that Pater picks some of his examples for the shape of his series, so it’s no surprise to watch the same instinct steering a single borrowed paragraph.

So the scene is legitimate if you read it as a map of consequences rather than a record of who attended a lecture. The historical core is solid, a crowded school, famous students and a condemned disciple, and the futures gathered around it are honest projections, labeled as visions. What Pater adds is a shift in where the crowd is heading, from Michelet’s revolution to his own worship of beauty, and my judgment is that the shift is fair as long as you notice it. The best way to read the passage is with two lists in hand, Michelet’s and Pater’s, and to watch the same students walk off the hill in two different directions.

Test your understanding

123

Question 1 of 3

How does Michelet’s list change as it develops?

Choose one answer

Guided Inquiry

Questions for Socrates

Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.