Renaissance

A Coat of Armor for a Grieving Family

Pater loved the silver gleam of a small London painting. In Giorgione’s Castelfranco altarpiece, that same armored figure stands beside the signs of a family’s grief.

The Costanzo chapel, the warrior saint and a later London panel show what the armor means within the altarpiece and how its meaning changes when the figure stands alone.

Orientation

At a Glance

  • Two armored figuresPater took the small London panel as an original study, while the National Gallery now assigns it to a later imitator.
  • The chapel supplies a contextTuzio Costanzo commissioned the Castelfranco altarpiece for the chapel where his son Matteo was buried.
  • The banner suggests a nameThe insignia of the Knights of Saint John supports identifying the figure as Nicasius, although Liberale and George have also been proposed.
  • The setting changes the armorThe tomb and the downward gaze of the holy figures give the armor a memorial context absent from the isolated London figure.

Pater’s eye goes straight to the metal of the saint’s armor. In Giorgione’s hometown, he says, stands “the altar-piece, foremost among his authentic works,” with “the figure of the warrior-saint, Liberale, of which the original little study in oil, with the delicately gleaming, silver-grey armour, is one of the greater treasures of the National Gallery.” There’s a twist in that sentence Pater couldn’t have known. The little London panel, which came to the National Gallery in 1855, is now catalogued as the work of a later imitator, probably of the seventeenth century, so the gleam he treasured in London was a copyist’s gleam, and the real armor still shines where Giorgione put it, above a family’s grave.

The commission explains why the real armor matters so much. Tuzio Costanzo, whom Pater calls “the famous condottiére,” using the Italian word for a mercenary captain, and “a picturesque remnant of medieval manners,” was a soldier associated with Messina who had served Caterina Cornaro, queen of Cyprus, before settling at Castelfranco. His son Matteo died young after serving Venice, and the father commissioned the altarpiece for the family’s funeral chapel, where Matteo’s tomb slab of 1504 lies below it. The Virgin sits on an unusually high throne set over a porphyry tomb carved with the family arms, three pairs of ribs, a pun on the name, since costa is Italian for rib, and the holy figures look down toward it. X-rays show that Giorgione changed the direction of the eyes. The alteration is visible in the evidence, even though the exact instructions behind it are uncertain.

The saint in armor has worn three different names over the years. Pater calls him Liberale, the patron of Castelfranco’s church, which makes the armor civic, the town’s own protector standing guard. Older viewers called him George, the dragon-slayer, which makes the armor generic chivalry, the knight every altarpiece needs. The city of Castelfranco identifies him as Nicasius, a martyred knight of the Hospitallers, on the evidence of the banner of the Knights of Saint John. Each name tells you whom the armor speaks for, the town, the ideal of knighthood or the family, and the identification as Nicasius has a specific foothold in the painting. Matteo’s tomb slab still lies in the floor just below the picture, so anyone standing in the chapel reads the banner and the grave together.

Some scholars go a step further and see Matteo’s own features in the young saint’s face. If that’s right, the armor isn’t decoration at all but a dead son’s armor, polished and offered up by a father who had spent his life in the same profession. It works the way a memorial photo of a fallen soldier in dress uniform works, where the shine on the buttons is part of the grief, a way of showing the young man at his best and most upright. The gleam Pater loved would then be the brightest thing in the picture for a reason, because the setting lets that gleam carry an association with the family’s mourning.

Pater offers a third reading and flags it himself. “In that figure, as in some other knightly personages attributed to him,” he writes, “people have supposed the likeness of the painter’s own presumably gracious presence.” The “presumably” admits that nobody knows what Giorgione looked like, but the nineteenth century badly wanted the handsome young genius inside the armor, the musician-lover who died at thirty-something, and it found him in every good-looking knight with his name attached. That reading tells you more about Victorian taste for beautiful, doomed artists than about Castelfranco in 1504.

Each reading sends your eye to a different place. The memorial reading pulls it down to the tomb and the arms and the Virgin’s lowered gaze, the saint reading pulls it to the banner and the view of the town in the background, and the self-portrait reading pulls it to the young man’s face and nothing else. The composition itself votes for the first, since everything in the picture steps down toward the porphyry box at its center, and the chapel’s history gives it a footing, so the shine on the steel is best read as a soldier’s profession turned into an offering by a soldier father. Even the landscape behind, with the walls of Castelfranco on one side, keeps the town in view without letting it take over from the family’s loss.

The London copy makes the same point, entirely by accident. The panel appears to draw on the armored saint, setting a related figure alone against a dark background, cutting away the throne, the tomb, the Virgin and the landscape, and turning a memorial saint into a portrait of a glamorous knight. That’s exactly the figure Pater fell for, gleaming and gracious and free of grief, which shows how much the meaning of the armor depends on the family chapel around it. Take the tomb away and the shine stops being mourning and becomes style.

So my verdict is that the armor in Castelfranco is first of all a coat made for a grieving family, given a memorial meaning by its place beside the Costanzo tomb, and the saint’s changing names matter because they decide whether we see that. The self-portrait legend belongs to the Victorians, and Pater was honest enough to mark it with a “presumably.” He was right about the delicate gleam and wrong about where to find it, since the true one isn’t in London at all but in a small chapel in Castelfranco, still shining over the Costanzo tomb.

Test your understanding

123

Question 1 of 3

Why does the article consider the identification of the armored saint as Nicasius especially meaningful?

Choose one answer

Guided Inquiry

Questions for Socrates

Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.