Tap the page, move to the top or bottom edge, swipe down, or press Tab to reveal reading controls. Use the arrow keys or swipe sideways to turn pages.
B942
Now probability is necessary for the other maxims, such as Lamy's and [that of] the slanderer.
By their fruits: judge their faith by their morals.
Probability is little without corrupt means, and the means are nothing without probability.
There is pleasure in being assured that one can act well and in knowing how to act well; grace—knowing and being able—and probability provide it, for one can give an account to God with assurance on the strength of their authors.
B943
Monsieur de Condren: There is, he says, no comparison between the union of the saints and that of the Holy Trinity. Jesus Christ says the opposite.
B944
There is a contradiction: on one side they say that tradition must be followed and would not dare disavow it; on the other, they will say whatever they please. People will always believe the first, since, in any case, not to believe it would be to oppose them.
B945
The day of judgment.
So that, Father, is what you call the sense of Jansenius: that, then, is what you convey to both pope and bishops.
If the Jesuits were corrupt and it were true that we were alone, all the more reason we should stand firm.
Let a false peace not take away what war has secured.
He is moved neither by blessing nor by curse, like an angel of the Lord.
They attack the greatest of Christian truths, which is love of truth.
If signing means that, let us explain it so that there may be no ambiguity; for we must agree that many believe signing indicates consent.
If the reporting judge did not sign, the decree would be invalidated; if the bull were not signed, it would be valid; therefore it is not…
But you may have been mistaken? — I swear that I believe I may have been mistaken; but I do not swear that I believe I have been mistaken.
One is not guilty for not believing, and one would be guilty for swearing without believing.
… fine questions, he…
I am sorry to tell you everything; I am merely giving an account.
That, together with Escobar, puts them in the seat of honor; but they do not take it that way, and showing distress at finding themselves between God and the pope.
B946
There is such a disproportion between the merit he thinks he has and his stupidity that one cannot believe he misunderstands himself so badly.
B946 bis
Annat. He plays the pupil without ignorance and the master without presumption.
B947
You abuse the belief the people have in the Church and make them believe.
B948
By corrupting the bishops and the Sorbonne, if they have not gained the advantage of making their judgment just, they have gained that of making their judges unjust. And so, when these judges condemn them in the future, they will argue against the persons that they are unjust, and thus refute their judgment. But that serves no purpose. For just as they cannot conclude that the Jansenists have been rightly condemned for the sole reason that they have been condemned, neither will they then be able to conclude that they themselves have been wrongly condemned because it will be by corruptible judges. For their condemnation will be just, not because it is delivered by judges who are always just, but by judges who are just in this instance; and that will be shown by the other proofs.
B949
Just as peace in states has no purpose but to keep the people's goods secure, so peace in the Church has no purpose but to keep truth secure, for truth is its good and the treasure where its heart is. And just as it would run counter to the purpose of peace to let foreigners enter a state and plunder it without resisting them, for fear of disturbing its repose—because peace is just and useful only for the security of that good, it becomes unjust and harmful when it lets the good be lost, and the war that can defend it becomes both just and necessary—so in the Church, when truth is attacked by the enemies of faith, when they wish to tear it from the hearts of the faithful so as to make error reign there, would remaining at peace then be serving the Church or betraying it? Would it be defending it or ruining it? And is it not evident that, just as it is a crime to disturb peace where truth reigns, it is also a crime to remain at peace when truth is being destroyed? There is therefore a time when peace is just and another when it is unjust. It is written that there is a time for peace and a time for war; and the interest of truth distinguishes them. But there is no time for truth and time for error; on the contrary, it is written that God's truth endures eternally. That is why Jesus Christ, who says that he came to bring peace, also says that he came to bring war. But he does not say that he came to bring both truth and falsehood. Truth is therefore the first rule and the final end of things.
B950
After tormenting you thoroughly, they will send you home.
That is as feeble a consolation as appeals against abuse, for one great means of abuse is—besides the fact that most will not have the means to come from the depths of Périgord and Anjou to plead before the Parlement of Paris—is that at every turn they will have decrees of the Council forbidding these appeals against abuse.
For even though they cannot obtain what they ask for, the request nevertheless displays their power, which is all the greater for having led them to ask for something so unjust that it is obvious they cannot obtain it.
It therefore only makes their intention better known, and the need not to authorize by registration the bull they want to make the basis of this new establishment.
This is no simple bull, but a foundation.
On leaving the law courts.
121. The pope forbids the king to marry off his children without his permission (1294).
If we wish, 124 (1302).
B951
In the bull Cum ex apostolatus officio, by Paul IV, published in 1558:
“We order, establish, decree, and define that each and every one of those found to have strayed or fallen into heresy or schism, of whatever rank or condition they may be—laymen, ecclesiastics, bishops, archbishops, patriarchs, primates, cardinals, counts, marquises, dukes, kings, and emperors—in addition to the sentences and penalties stated above, shall by that very fact, without any procedure in law or fact, be wholly and perpetually deprived of their orders, bishoprics, benefices, offices, kingdom, and empire, and forever incapable of returning to them.
“We leave them to the discretion of the secular power to be punished; we grant no other favor to those who, moved by true penitence, return from their error, except that, by the kindness and clemency of the Holy See, they shall be deemed worthy of confinement in a monastery, there to do perpetual penance on bread and water. But they shall always remain deprived of all dignity, order, prelacy, county, duchy, and kingdom. And those who harbor and defend them shall by that very fact be judged excommunicate and infamous, deprived of every kingdom, duchy, good, and possession, which shall belong by right and ownership to the first to seize them.
“If… they exterminate, they will be justified. 23, question 5, of Urban II. We do not regard as murderers those who, burning with zeal for the Catholic mother, have happened to kill any of the excommunicated.”
B952
Since the Church's two principal concerns are to preserve the piety of the faithful and to convert heretics, we are overwhelmed with sorrow to see the factions being formed today to introduce the errors most capable of closing forever to heretics the entrance to our communion and of mortally corrupting the devout and Catholic people who remain to us. This undertaking, pursued so openly today against the truths of religion most important to salvation, fills us not only with distress but also with terror and fear: for, besides the feeling every Christian must have at these disorders, we have the further obligation to remedy them and to employ the authority God has given us so that the peoples he has entrusted to us, etc.