Tap the page, move to the top or bottom edge, swipe down, or press Tab to reveal reading controls. Use the arrow keys or swipe sideways to turn pages.
B925
Examine the motive for the censure through the phenomena: form a hypothesis that fits them all.
The habit makes the doctrine.
[You hear the confessions of so many people who confess only once a year.]
[I thought there was one opinion against another.]
[When one is so wicked that one no longer feels any remorse, one cannot displease. You therefore persecute Monsieur Arnauld without remorse.]
I distrust this doctrine, for it is too gentle with me for the wickedness they say is in me.
I distrust their union, given their particular contradictions. I shall wait for them to agree before taking sides. For one friend I would have too many enemies. I am not learned enough to answer them.
[Why did you not choose some substantial heresy!]
[The wager.]
[I certainly thought one could be damned for not having had good thoughts; but for believing no one has any, that is new to me.]
[What use is that? To console the just and ward off despair? — No, for no one can be in a position to believe himself just.
[Monsieur Chamillard would be a heretic—which is manifestly false—for he has written in support of Monsieur Arnauld.
— Those who believe they are doing good when they sin.]
In the year 1647, grace for everyone; in 1650, it became rarer, etc.
Luther — everything except the truth.
If there had not been similar occasions in the Church; but I take my parish priest's word for it.
Only one speaks the truth.
However little it inconveniences them, they make others (graces), for they dispose of them as their own handiwork. [For every occasion, a grace; for every person: grace for the great, grace for scoundrels.]
In short, Monsieur Chamillard is so close to it that, if there are steps for descending into nothingness, this sufficient grace is now on the nearest one.
[Amusing to be a heretic for that!]
There is no one who would not be surprised at it; for it has never been seen in Scripture or the Fathers, etc.
How long has it been an article of faith, Father? At most, only since the words 'proximate power'; and I believe that at its birth it created this heresy, and that it was born for that purpose alone.
[The censure forbids only speaking of Saint Peter in this way, and nothing more.]
[I am much obliged to them. They are clever men; they were afraid that the letters written to people in the provinces…
It is not worth the trouble for one word.
I think they are sorcerers. Everything is said except the truth. Member — Heretic. One holy.
The Illuminations have done me harm.
A proposition is good in one author and bad in another.
Yes; but then there are other bad propositions.
Some people defer to the censure; others to reasons; and everyone to reasons. I am therefore surprised you have not taken the general path instead of the particular one, or at least joined it to the other.
How relieved I am! No Frenchman a good Catholic.
The… Clement VIII — Paul V — Censure.
God visibly protects us.
“Man is quite senseless. He cannot make a mite.”
Instead of desiring grace to go there. Plurality of graces.
Jansenist translations.
Saint Augustine has the most because of the divisions among his friends. Besides, something one may consider an uninterrupted tradition of twelve thousand popes, councils, etc.
Monsieur Arnauld must therefore have many bad beliefs, to infect those he embraces.
The censure does them this good only when they themselves are censured; they will fight it by saying that they are imitating the Jansenists.
B926
One must hear both sides; I have taken care to do so.
When one has heard only one side, one is always on that side; but the opposing side makes one change, whereas here the Jesuit confirms it.
Not what they do, but what they say.
It is only against me that they cry out. Very well: I know to whom I must give an account.
Jesus Christ was a stumbling stone.
Deserving condemnation, condemned.
Policy. — We have found two obstacles to the plan of easing people's burdens: one, the inward laws of the Gospel; the other, the outward laws of the state and religion. Of the former we are masters; with the latter, this is how we have proceeded: to be extended, to be restricted, from the greater to the lesser. Junior.
Probable. If reasons as bad as these are probable, everything will be:
First reason. Master of conjugal acts. Molina.
Second reason. It cannot be compensated for. Lessius.
Set against them not holy maxims, but abominable ones.
They reason like people who show that it is night at noon: Bauny, burner of barns.
… Council of Trent concerning priests in mortal sin: as soon as possible…
B927
Your mad idea of the importance of your Society has led you to establish these horrible practices. It is quite clear that this is what made you follow the path of slander, since you condemn as horrible in me the same impostures you excuse in yourselves, because you regard me as a private individual and yourselves as the Image.
It is clear that your praises are follies, from follies such as the privilege of not being damned.
Is it encouraging your children to condemn them when they serve the Church?
It is a trick of the devil to divert elsewhere the weapons with which those people fought heresies.
You are bad politicians.
B928
Diana. — [That is very useful to us.] Fundamental corruption.
11. It is permissible not to give benefices that carry no care of souls to the most worthy. The Council of Trent seems to say the opposite; but here is how he proves it: For if that were so, all prelates would be in a state of damnation, since they all act in this way.
The king and the pope are not obliged to choose the most worthy. If that were so, the pope and kings would have a terrible burden.
And elsewhere: 21. If this opinion were not true, penitents and confessors would have a great deal of trouble, and that is why I think it must be followed in practice.”
And in another place, 22, where he sets out the conditions necessary to make a sin mortal, he includes so many circumstances that one scarcely ever sins mortally; and after establishing this, he exclaims: Oh, how sweet and light is the Lord's yoke!
And elsewhere: 11. One is not obliged to give alms from one's surplus for the ordinary needs of the poor; if the opposite were true, most rich people and their confessors would have to be condemned.
These reasons were making me impatient when I said to the Father: But what prevents us from saying that they are? — He has anticipated that too in this passage, he answered me, where, after saying, If that were true, the richest people would be damned, he adds: 22. To this Arragonius replies that they are indeed; and Báñez adds that their confessors are too. But I answer with Valentia, another Jesuit, and other authors, that there are several reasons to excuse these rich people and their confessors.
I was delighted with this reasoning when he finished me off with the following. If this opinion were true concerning restitution, oh, how much restitution there would be to make!
— Oh, Father, I said to him, what a fine reason! — Oh! the Father said to me, what an accommodating man you are! — Oh, Father, I answered, how many people will be damned without your casuists! Oh, how broad you make the path that leads to heaven! Oh, how many people find it! Here is a…
B929
[And they are preparing to drive from the Church those who refuse this admission. In v…] Everyone declares that they are.
Monsieur Arnauld (and his friends) declares that he condemns them in themselves and wherever they may be found; that, if they are in Jansenius, he condemns them there; that even if they are not there, if the heretical sense of these propositions condemned by the pope is found in Jansenius, he condemns Jansenius.
But you are not satisfied with these declarations: you want him to affirm that these propositions are in Jansenius word for word. He has answered that he cannot affirm it, not knowing whether it is so; that he and countless others have looked for them there without ever finding them. They have begged you and all your people to cite the pages on which they occur; no one has ever done so. And yet you want to cut him off from the Church for this refusal, although he condemns everything it condemns, for this sole reason: that he does not affirm that certain words, or a sense, occur in a book where he has never found them and where no one will show them to him. Truly, Father, this pretext is so empty that perhaps there has never been in the Church a proceeding so strange, so unjust, and so reckless as…
The Church certainly can oblige.
One need not be a theologian to see that their heresy consists only in their opposition to you. I experience it myself, and the general proof is seen in all who have attacked you: the parish priests of Rouen, Jansenists… of Caen.
You believe your designs so honorable that you make them the matter of a vow.
Two years ago their heresy was the bull; last year it was inward; six months ago it was word for word; now it is the sense.
Do I not see clearly that you want only to make them heretics? Blessed Sacrament. Preface. Villeloin…
Jansenius — Aurelius — Arnauld — Provincial Letters.
I have quarreled with you by speaking for others.
You are quite ridiculous to make a noise about the propositions; it is nothing. It must be understood.
Without authors' names; but since your design was known, seventy opposed it.
Date the decree.
So that the man you had been unable to make a heretic on his own words, etc.
[That I have demonstrated that all this comes from your authors, down to the most horrible things.] For everything becomes known.
[Is that all you have to answer, and that way of proving it?]
Either he knows that it is so, or that it is not, or he doubts; either a sinner or a heretic.
Considering only the pagans.
The same light that discloses supernatural truths discloses them without error, whereas the light that…
[A body of the reprobate. Every collection box at Saint-Merri could be opened without your being any less innocent.]
[Nor is that strange… False right… For my part, I would rather be unjustly than.]
What reason have you for it? You say I am a Jansenist, that Port-Royal upholds the five propositions, and that I therefore uphold them: three lies.
And please do not come and tell me that you are not the ones setting all this in motion. Spare me the reply. I would answer you with things that would please neither you nor others.
The pope did not condemn two things; he condemned only the sense of the propositions. Will you say that he did not condemn it? — But the sense of Jansenius is contained in them, says the pope. — I can well see that the pope thinks so because of your 'word for word'; but he did not say it on pain of excommunication. How could he and the bishops of France not have believed it? You said 'word for word,' and they did not know that you have the power to say it even when it is not so. Impostors, they had not seen my fifteenth letter.
How could the sense of Jansenius be in propositions that are not his?
Either it is in Jansenius or it is not. If it is, then he is condemned in that respect; if it is not, why do you want to have him condemned?
Let just one of your Father Escobar's propositions be condemned: I will go with Escobar in one hand and the censure in the other, and make a formal argument of it.