Tap the page, move to the top or bottom edge, swipe down, or press Tab to reveal reading controls. Use the arrow keys or swipe sideways to turn pages.
B903
All the world's religions and sects have had natural reason as their guide. Christians alone have been bound to take their rules from outside themselves and inquire into those Jesus Christ left to the ancients to be transmitted to the faithful. This constraint tires these good Fathers: they want, like other peoples, freedom to follow their imaginations. In vain we cry to them, as the prophets once said to the Jews: Go into the midst of the Church; inquire into the ways the ancients left it, and follow those paths.—They have answered like the Jews: We will not walk in them, but will follow the thoughts of our heart; and they said, We will be like the other peoples.
B904
They make the exception the rule.
The ancients gave absolution before penitence—do so in the spirit of an exception. But you make the exception a rule without exception, so that you no longer even wish the rule to be an exception.
B905
On confessions and absolutions without signs of regret.—God regards only the inward; the Church judges only by the outward. God absolves as soon as he sees penitence in the heart; the Church when it sees it in works. God will make a Church pure within, whose inward and wholly spiritual holiness confounds the inward impiety of proud sages and Pharisees; the Church will make an assembly whose outward morals are so pure that they confound pagan morals. If there are hypocrites, but so well disguised that it does not recognize their poison, it tolerates them; for though they are not received by God, whom they cannot deceive, they are received by men, whom they deceive. Thus it is not dishonored by their conduct, which appears holy. But you want the Church to judge neither the inward, because that belongs to God alone, nor the outward, because God considers only the inward. Thus, depriving it of all discrimination among people, you retain in the Church the most dissolute, those who dishonor it so greatly that Jewish synagogues and philosophical sects would have expelled them as unworthy and abhorred them as impious.
B906
The conditions easiest to live in according to the world are hardest to live in according to God, and conversely. Nothing is so hard by worldly standards as the religious life; nothing is easier than living it according to God. Nothing is easier by worldly standards than holding great office and great possessions; nothing is harder than living there according to God without taking a share or delight in them.
B907
Casuists submit the decision to corrupted reason and the choice of decisions to corrupted will, so that everything corrupt in human nature has a share in directing conduct.
B908
But is it probable that probability gives assurance?
Difference between peace and security of conscience. Nothing gives assurance but truth; nothing gives peace but the sincere search for truth.
B909
The entire company of their casuists cannot give a conscience security in error; that is why it matters to choose good guides.
They will therefore be doubly guilty: both for following paths they should not have followed and for listening to teachers they should not have listened to.
B910
Can anything but a wish to please the world make you find these things probable? Will you make us believe that truth does so, and that, if dueling were not fashionable, you would find it probable that one may fight, considering the thing in itself?
B911
Must we kill to prevent there being wicked people? — That makes two instead of one: Overcome evil with good. (Saint Augustine.)
B912
Universal. — Morality — and language — are particular sciences, but universal ones.
B913
Probability. — Anyone can put in; no one can take out.
B914
They let concupiscence act and hold scruple in check, when they should do the reverse.