Tap the page, move to the top or bottom edge, swipe down, or press Tab to reveal reading controls. Use the arrow keys or swipe sideways to turn pages.

← ExitPensées
Section XIII

B846

Explanatory notes

‘First objection: Angel from heaven. Truth must not be judged by miracles, but miracles by truth. Therefore miracles are useless.’

Yet they are useful, and one must not be against truth; therefore what Father Lingendes said, that God will not allow a miracle to lead into error…

When there is a dispute within the same Church, the miracle will decide.

Second objection: But the Antichrist will perform signs.

Pharaoh's magicians did not entice people into unavoidable error. Thus no one will be able to say to Jesus Christ concerning the Antichrist, You enticed me into error.—For the Antichrist will perform signs against Jesus Christ, and thus they cannot lead into unavoidable error. Either God will not allow false miracles, or he will provide greater ones.

[Jesus Christ has endured since the beginning of the world: that is stronger than all the Antichrist's miracles.]

If a miracle occurred on the mistaken side within the same Church, people would be led into error. Schism is visible; the miracle is visible. But schism is a stronger sign of error than the miracle is of truth; therefore the miracle cannot lead into error.

But outside schism, error is not as visible as the miracle is; therefore the miracle would lead into error.

Where is your God? Miracles show him and are a flash of light.

B847

One of the antiphons at Christmas vespers: Light has risen in darkness for the upright in heart.

B848

If God's mercy is so great that he teaches us for our salvation even when he hides himself, what light should we not expect from him when he reveals himself?

B849

Explanatory notes

Will It is and it is not be accepted in faith itself, as well as in miracles? And if it is inseparable from it in the others…

When Saint Xavier performs miracles.—[Saint Hilary.—Wretched men, who force us to speak of miracles.] Woe to you who enact.

Unjust judges, do not make laws on the spot; judge by those already established, and established by yourselves: Woe to you who enact unjust laws.

Continual miracles, false.

To weaken your adversaries, you disarm the whole Church.

If they say our salvation depends on God, they are heretics. If they say they submit to the pope, it is hypocrisy. If they are ready to subscribe to all his constitutions, that is not enough. If they say one must not kill for an apple, they attack Catholic morality. If miracles take place among them, that is no sign of holiness; on the contrary, it raises suspicion of heresy.

The way the Church has endured is that truth has been undisputed; or, if disputed, there has been the pope; or, failing that, there has been the Church.

B850

The five propositions condemned: no miracle, for truth was not being attacked. But the Sorbonne…, but the bull…

It is impossible for those who love God with all their heart not to recognize the Church, so evident is it.—It is impossible for those who do not love God to be convinced of the Church.

Miracles have such force that God had to warn us not to consider them against him, however clear it may be that there is a God; otherwise they would have been capable of unsettling us.

Thus, far from counting against the authority of miracles, these passages in Deuteronomy 13 show their power more than anything else. Likewise with the Antichrist: ‘Even to deceive the elect, if that were possible.’

B851

Explanatory notes

The story of the man born blind.

What does Saint Paul say? Does he speak at every moment of the correspondence of prophecies? No, but of his miracle. What does Jesus Christ say? Does he speak of the correspondence of prophecies? No: his death had not yet fulfilled them; but he says, If I had not done. Believe the works.

Two supernatural foundations of our wholly supernatural religion: one visible, the other invisible. Miracles with grace, miracles without grace.

The synagogue, treated with love as a figure of the Church and with hatred because it was only the figure, was raised up when about to succumb, when it stood well with God; and thus a figure.

Miracles prove God's power over hearts through the power he exercises over bodies.

The Church has never approved a miracle among heretics.

Miracles, support of religion: they have distinguished Jews, Christians, saints, the innocent, true believers.

A miracle among schismatics is less to be feared, for schism, more visible than the miracle, visibly marks their error. But where there is no schism and error is disputed, the miracle distinguishes.

If I had not done what no other has done. Those wretched men who have forced us to speak of miracles.

Abraham, Gideon: confirming faith through miracles.

Judith: finally God speaks under the utmost oppression.

If the cooling of charity leaves the Church almost without true worshipers, miracles will raise them up. It is one of the final effects of grace.

If a miracle occurred among the Jesuits!

When a miracle defeats the expectation of those in whose presence it occurs, and there is a disproportion between the state of their faith and the miracle's instrument, then it should move them to change. But in your case, otherwise. There would be as much reason to say that, if the Eucharist raised a dead man, one ought to become a Calvinist as to remain Catholic. But when it crowns expectation, and those who hoped God would bless the remedies find themselves healed without remedies…

The impious.—Never has a sign come from the devil without a stronger sign from God, at least without its having been foretold that it would happen.

B852

Explanatory notes

Unjust persecutors of those whom God visibly protects: if they reproach you for your excesses, they speak like heretics; if they say Jesus Christ's grace distinguishes us, ‘they are heretics’; if miracles occur, ‘that is the sign of their heresy.’

Ezekiel. People say: There are God's people speaking thus.—Hezekiah.

It is said, ‘Believe the Church,’ but not, ‘Believe miracles,’ because the latter is natural and the former is not. One needed a precept, the other did not.

The synagogue was the figure and thus did not perish; it was only the figure and thus has perished. It was a figure containing truth, and thus endured until it no longer possessed truth.

Reverend Father, all this took place in figure. The other religions perish; this one does not.

Miracles are more important than you think: they served to found the Church and will serve to continue it, until the Antichrist, until the end.

The two Witnesses.

In the Old and New Testaments, miracles are performed through attachment to figures. Salvation, or something useless except to show that one must submit to the Scriptures: figures of the sacraments.

B853

[One must judge divine ordinances soberly, Father.

Saint Paul on the island of Malta.]

B855

I assume that miracles are believed: you corrupt religion either in favor of your friends or against your enemies. You dispose of it as you please.

B856

On the miracle.—As God has made no family happier, may he also grant that he finds none more grateful.

Contents

Sign in to save your reading →