Tap the page, move to the top or bottom edge, swipe down, or press Tab to reveal reading controls. Use the arrow keys or swipe sideways to turn pages.

← ExitPensées
Section XIII

B838

Explanatory notes

Jesus Christ performed miracles, and the apostles afterward, and the earliest saints, in great numbers; for, since the prophecies were not yet fulfilled and were being fulfilled through them, nothing bore witness but miracles. It was foretold that the Messiah would convert the nations. How could this prophecy have been fulfilled without the nations' conversion? And how could the nations have been converted to the Messiah without seeing this final effect of the prophecies that prove him? Before he had died, risen, and converted the nations, therefore, everything was not fulfilled; so miracles were necessary throughout that time. Now no more are needed against the Jews, for fulfilled prophecies are an enduring miracle.

B839

Explanatory notes

‘If you do not believe in me, believe at least in the miracles.’ He refers them to what is strongest.

The Jews, like Christians, had been told not always to believe prophets; nevertheless the Pharisees and scribes attach great importance to his miracles and try to show they are false or performed by the devil, since they would necessarily be convinced if they acknowledged them as God's.

We are not burdened today with making this distinction. Yet it is quite easy to make: those who deny neither God nor Jesus Christ perform no miracles that are not certain. No one performs a mighty work in my name and can soon speak ill of me.

But we do not have to make this distinction. Here is a sacred relic; here is a thorn from the crown of the Savior of the world, over whom the prince of this world has no power, working miracles through the very power of the blood shed for us. Here God himself chooses this house to display his power.

These are not men performing miracles through an unknown and doubtful power that obliges us to make a difficult distinction. It is God himself; it is the instrument of his only Son's Passion, which, being present in several places, chooses this one and brings people from every direction to receive these miraculous alleviations of their infirmities.

B840

Explanatory notes

The Church has three kinds of enemies: the Jews, who have never belonged to its body; heretics, who have withdrawn from it; and bad Christians, who tear it apart from within.

These three different kinds of adversaries usually fight it in different ways; but here they fight it in the same way. Since all lack miracles, and the Church has always had miracles against them, all have had the same interest in evading them and all have used this evasion: doctrine must not be judged by miracles, but miracles by doctrine. There were two parties among those who listened to Jesus Christ: some followed his doctrine because of his miracles; others said… There were two parties in Calvin's time… Now there are the Jesuits, and so on.

B841

Explanatory notes

Miracles distinguish doubtful matters: between the Jewish and pagan peoples, Jewish and Christian; Catholic, heretic; the slandered and the slanderers; between the two crosses.

But miracles would be useless for heretics, for the Church, authorized by miracles that have already established belief, tells us they do not have true faith. There is no doubt that they are outside it, since the Church's first miracles exclude faith in theirs. Thus there is miracle against miracle, with the earlier and greater ones on the Church's side.

These girls, astonished at what is said—that they are on the path to perdition, that their confessors are leading them to Geneva, that they teach them Jesus Christ is neither in the Eucharist nor at the Father's right hand—know that all this is false. In this condition they offer themselves to God: See whether there is a way of iniquity in me. What happens then? This place, called the devil's temple, God makes his temple. People say the children must be removed: God heals them there. People say it is hell's arsenal: God makes it the sanctuary of his graces. Finally, they are threatened with all heaven's fury and vengeance, and God showers them with his favors. One would have to have lost one's senses to conclude that they are therefore on the path to perdition.

(We undoubtedly have the same signs as Saint Athanasius.)

B842

Explanatory notes

‘If you are the Christ, tell us.’

‘The works I do in my Father's name bear witness to me. But you do not believe because you are not of my sheep. My sheep hear my voice.’

John 6:30. ‘What sign, then, do you perform, so that we may see and believe you?’—They do not say: What doctrine do you preach?

‘No one can perform the signs you perform unless God is with him.’

2 Maccabees 14:15. ‘God, who protects his portion with evident signs.’

‘We wish to see a sign from heaven,’ putting him to the test. Luke 11:16.

‘An evil generation seeks a sign, and none will be given. And, groaning, he said: Why does this generation seek a sign?’ (Mark 8:12.) It asked for a sign with an evil intention.

‘And he could not perform.’ Yet he promises them Jonah's sign, that of his resurrection, the great and incomparable sign.

‘Unless you see signs, you do not believe.’ He blames them not for failing to believe without miracles, but for failing to believe without witnessing them themselves.

—The Antichrist, ‘with lying signs,’ says Saint Paul, 2 Thessalonians 2, ‘according to Satan's working, deceiving those who perish because they did not receive the love of truth so as to be saved; therefore God will send upon them workings of error so that they believe the lie.’ As in Moses' passage: For God tests you to see whether you love him.

See, I have foretold it to you: take heed, then.

B843

Explanatory notes

This is not truth's country: it wanders unknown among men. God has covered it with a veil that leaves it unrecognized by those who do not understand its voice. The place lies open to blasphemy, even against truths at least quite apparent. If the truths of the Gospel are published, contrary ones are published too, and the questions are obscured so that ordinary people cannot distinguish them. Then people ask: What have you to make us believe you rather than the others? What sign do you perform? You have only words, and so do we. If you had miracles, well and good.—It is true that doctrine must be supported by miracles; that truth is abused to blaspheme doctrine. And if miracles occur, people say miracles do not suffice without doctrine; and that is another truth used to blaspheme miracles.

Jesus Christ healed the man born blind and performed many miracles on the sabbath, thereby blinding the Pharisees who said that miracles must be judged by doctrine.

‘We have Moses, but as for this man, we do not know where he comes from.’ The astonishing thing is that you do not know where he comes from, yet he performs such miracles.

Jesus Christ spoke neither against God nor against Moses.

The Antichrist and false prophets, foretold by both Testaments, will speak openly against God and Jesus Christ. One who is not hidden… Were someone a concealed enemy, God would not allow him openly to perform miracles.

Never in a public dispute where both parties profess allegiance to God, Jesus Christ, and the Church are miracles on the side of false Christians and the other side without a miracle.

‘He has the devil.’ John 10:21.—And others said: ‘Can the devil open blind people's eyes?’

The proofs Jesus Christ and the apostles draw from Scripture are not demonstrative: they say only that Moses said a prophet would come, but do not thereby prove that this is the one, which was the whole question. These passages therefore serve only to show that one is not contrary to Scripture and that no incompatibility appears, not that there is agreement. Now that suffices: exclusion of incompatibility, together with a miracle.

There is a reciprocal duty between God and men. Forgive this expression: What was I bound to do? ‘Accuse me,’ God says in Isaiah.

God must fulfill his promises, and so on.

Men owe it to God to receive the religion he sends them. God owes it to men not to lead them into error. Now they would be led into error if workers [of] miracles announced a doctrine not visibly false by the lights of common sense, and if a greater worker of miracles had not already warned against believing them.

Thus, if there were division in the Church and the Arians, for example, who claimed a foundation in Scripture as the Catholics did, had performed miracles and the Catholics had not, people would have been led into error.

For just as a man announcing God's secrets is not worthy of belief on his private authority—and this is why the impious doubt them—so, when a man, as a sign of his communication with God, raises the dead, foretells the future, moves seas, and heals the sick, no impious person fails to yield. The unbelief of Pharaoh and the Pharisees is the effect of a supernatural hardening.

When, therefore, miracles and unsuspected doctrine are seen together on one side, there is no difficulty. But when miracles and suspect doctrine are seen on the same side, one must see which is clearer. Jesus Christ was suspect.

Bar-Jesus blinded: God's power overcomes his enemies' power.

The Jewish exorcists beaten by the devils, who say: ‘I know Jesus and Paul, but who are you?’

Miracles are for doctrine, not doctrine for miracles.

If miracles are true, can any doctrine be persuaded upon us? No, for that will not happen. If an angel…

Rule: Doctrine must be judged by miracles; miracles must be judged by doctrine. All this is true, but it is not contradictory, for the times must be distinguished.

How pleased you are to know the general rules, thinking thereby to throw everything into confusion and make it useless! You will be prevented, Father: truth is one and firm.

Because of God's duty, it is impossible for a man who conceals his bad doctrine, shows only a good one, and professes agreement with God and the Church to perform miracles in order imperceptibly to slip in a false and subtle doctrine. This cannot be.

Still less can God, who knows hearts, perform miracles in such a man's favor.

B844

Explanatory notes

The three marks of religion: perpetuity, a good life, miracles. They destroy perpetuity through probabilism, a good life through their morality, miracles by destroying either their truth or their consequence.

If they are believed, the Church will have no need of perpetuity, holiness, or miracles. Heretics deny them or deny their consequence; these men do the same. But one would have to lack sincerity to deny them, or further lose one's senses to deny their consequence.

No one has ever submitted to martyrdom for miracles he says he has seen; for [as regards] those the Turks believe by tradition, human folly perhaps goes as far as martyrdom, but not for those one has seen.

B844 bis

Explanatory notes

Perpetuity.—Molina: novelty.

B845

Heretics have always fought these three marks, which they do not possess.

Contents

Sign in to save your reading →