Tap the page, move to the top or bottom edge, swipe down, or press Tab to reveal reading controls. Use the arrow keys or swipe sideways to turn pages.
Section XIII
Historical thematic sequence · Brunschvicg edition
B803
Beginning.—Miracles distinguish doctrine, and doctrine distinguishes miracles.
There are false ones and true ones. We need a sign by which to recognize them; otherwise they would be useless. Now they are not useless, but on the contrary foundational. The rule he gives us must therefore be such that it does not destroy the proof true miracles give of truth, which is the principal purpose of miracles.
Moses gave two: that the prediction does not come to pass, Deuteronomy 18, and that they do not lead to idolatry, Deuteronomy 13; and Jesus Christ one.
If doctrine governs miracles, miracles are useless for doctrine.
If miracles govern…
Objection to the rule.—Distinguishing the times. One rule in Moses' time, another now.
B804
Miracle.—An effect exceeding the natural power of the means employed; and a non-miracle is an effect that does not exceed the natural power of the means employed. Thus those who heal by invoking the devil perform no miracle, for this does not exceed the devil's natural power. But…
B805
The two foundations, one inward, the other outward: grace, miracles; both supernatural.
B806
Miracles and truth are necessary because the whole person must be convinced, in body and soul.
B807
Always either people have spoken of the true God, or the true God has spoken to people.
B808
Jesus Christ established that he was the Messiah, never by verifying his doctrine against Scripture and the prophecies, but always through his miracles.
He proves through a miracle that he forgives sins.
‘Do not rejoice in your miracles,’ says Jesus Christ, ‘but that your names are written in heaven.’
If they do not believe Moses, they will not believe someone risen from the dead.
Nicodemus recognizes through his miracles that his doctrine is from God: We know that you have come from God as a teacher; for no one can do what you do unless God is with him. He judges not the miracles by the doctrine, but the doctrine by the miracles.
The Jews had a doctrine from God, as we have one from Jesus Christ, confirmed by miracles; and a prohibition against believing every worker of miracles, and moreover a command to consult the high priests and abide by them.
Thus they had, regarding their prophets, all the reasons we have for refusing to believe workers of miracles.
Yet, because of the miracles, they were gravely guilty of rejecting the prophets and Jesus Christ; and would not have been guilty had they not seen the miracles: If I had not done…, they would have no sin. Thus all belief rests upon miracles.
Prophecy is not called a miracle: thus Saint John speaks of the first miracle at Cana, then of what Jesus Christ says to the Samaritan woman, disclosing her entire hidden life; then he heals the son of an officer, and Saint John calls this ‘the second sign.’
B809
The combinations of miracles.
B810
The second miracle can presuppose the first; the first cannot presuppose the second.
B811
Without the miracles, one would not have sinned in not believing Jesus Christ.
B812
I would not be a Christian without miracles, says Saint Augustine.
B813
Miracles.—How I hate those who play the doubter about miracles! Montaigne speaks of them as he should in the two passages. In one we see how prudent he is; yet in the other he believes and mocks unbelievers.
However that may be, the Church has no proof if they are right.
B814
Montaigne against miracles.
Montaigne for miracles.