Tap the page, move to the top or bottom edge, swipe down, or press Tab to reveal reading controls. Use the arrow keys or swipe sideways to turn pages.
Section II
Historical thematic sequence · Brunschvicg edition
B60
First part: Human wretchedness without God.
Second part: Human happiness with God.
Alternatively:
First part: That nature is corrupt, shown through nature itself.
Second part: That there is a Restorer, shown through Scripture.
B61
Order.—I could well have arranged this discourse like this one: to show the vanity of all sorts of conditions, show the vanity of ordinary lives, then that of philosophical lives—Pyrrhonist, Stoic. But order would not be observed. I know a little of what it is, and how few people understand it. No human science can observe it: Saint Thomas did not observe it. Mathematics observes it, but in its depths it is useless.
B62
Preface to the first part.—Speak of those who have treated self-knowledge: Charron’s divisions, which sadden and bore; Montaigne’s confusion; how he had clearly sensed the defect of [a sound] method, how he avoided it by jumping from subject to subject, how he sought a pleasing manner. What a foolish project, to portray himself! And not in passing and against his own maxims, as everyone happens to fail, but according to his own maxims and as his first and principal purpose. For to say foolish things by chance and through weakness is an ordinary evil; but to say them deliberately is unbearable, and to say such things as these…
B63
Montaigne.—Montaigne’s faults are great. Lewd words: worthless, whatever Mademoiselle de Gournay may say. Credulous: people without eyes. Ignorant: squaring the circle, a larger world. His views on suicide, on death. He inspires indifference to salvation, without fear or repentance. His book was not written to foster piety, so he had no obligation to do that; but we are always obliged not to turn people away from it. His somewhat free and sensual opinions in certain circumstances of life can be excused (730, 331), but his wholly pagan views on death cannot. For we must renounce all piety if we do not at least wish to die as Christians; yet throughout his book he thinks only of dying weakly and softly.
B64
It is within myself, rather than in Montaigne, that I find everything I see in him.
B65
What is good in Montaigne can be acquired only with difficulty. What is bad—I mean apart from his morals—could have been corrected in a moment, had someone warned him that he told too many stories and spoke too much about himself.
B66
We must know ourselves: even if that did not help us find truth, it would at least help us regulate our lives, and nothing is more fitting.
B67
Vanity of the sciences.—Knowledge of external things will not console me in a time of affliction for ignorance of morality; but knowledge of conduct will always console me for ignorance of the external sciences.
B68
People are taught everything except how to be cultivated persons; yet there is nothing else they take so much pride in knowing as how to be cultivated persons. They pride themselves on knowing the one thing they do not learn.
B69
When we read too quickly or too slowly, we understand nothing.
B69 bis
Two infinities, middle.—When we read too quickly or too slowly, we understand nothing.
B70
Nature [cannot]…—[Nature has placed us so firmly in the middle that, if we alter one side of the balance, we also alter the other: “I do,” with a plural verb; “the animals runs.” This makes me believe that there are springs in our heads so arranged that touching one also touches its opposite.]