Tap the page, move to the top or bottom edge, swipe down, or press Tab to reveal reading controls. Use the arrow keys or swipe sideways to turn pages.
B566
We understand nothing of God’s works unless we take as a principle that he wished to blind some and enlighten others.
B567
The two contrary reasons. We must begin there: without this, nothing is understood and everything is heretical. Even at the end of every truth, we must add that we remember the opposing truth.
B568
Objection. Scripture is visibly full of things not dictated by the Holy Spirit.—Reply. Therefore they do not harm faith.—Objection. But the Church has decided that everything is from the Holy Spirit.—Reply. I answer two things: that the Church has never decided this; and, second, that even if it had decided it, this could be sustained.
There [are] many minds that judge falsely.
Denys has charity; he held office.
The prophecies quoted in the Gospel: do you believe they are reported to make you believe? No, it is to turn you away from believing.
B569
Canonical books.—The heretics at the beginning of the Church serve to prove the canonical books.
B570
In the chapter on Foundations, put what is in the one on Figurative Meanings concerning the cause of the figures: why Jesus Christ was prophesied in his first advent; why prophesied obscurely in the manner.
B571
Reason for figures.—[They had to sustain a carnal people and make it the keeper of the spiritual Testament]: to give credence to the Messiah, there had to have been previous prophecies, carried by people beyond suspicion, of extraordinary diligence, fidelity, and zeal, and known throughout the earth.
To make all this succeed, God chose this carnal people and entrusted to it the prophecies foretelling the Messiah as deliverer and dispenser of the carnal goods it loved. Thus it had extraordinary ardor for its prophets and carried in full view of everyone these books foretelling its Messiah, assuring all nations that he must come in the manner foretold in the books it held open to everyone. This people, disappointed by the Messiah’s shameful and impoverished advent, therefore became his cruelest enemies. Here, then, is the people in the world least suspected of favoring us, and as exact and zealous as can be said for its law and prophets, which it carries uncorrupted. Thus those who rejected and crucified Jesus Christ, who was a stumbling block to them, are those who carry the books testifying to him and saying he will be rejected and a stumbling block. Thus in refusing him they marked that it was he, and he was equally proved both by the righteous Jews who received him and the unrighteous who rejected him, both having been foretold.
That is why the prophecies have a hidden meaning, the spiritual meaning this people opposed, beneath the carnal meaning it favored. Had the spiritual meaning been disclosed, they would have been incapable of loving it and could not have carried it: they would not have been zealous to preserve their books and ceremonies. And if they [had] loved these spiritual promises and preserved them uncorrupted until the Messiah, their testimony would have had no force, since they would have favored them.
That is why it was good for the spiritual meaning to be covered. But on the other hand, if it had been so hidden that it did not appear at all, it could not have served as proof for the Messiah. What, then, was done? It was covered beneath the temporal meaning in the mass of passages, and disclosed so clearly in some; besides, the time and the state of the world were foretold so clearly that it is clearer than the sun. This spiritual meaning is so clearly explained in some places that it took a blindness like that cast by the flesh into the mind when the mind is subjected to it not to recognize it.
That, then, was God’s ordering. This meaning is covered by another in countless places and disclosed in a few, rarely; yet in such a way that the places where it is hidden are ambiguous and can fit both, whereas the places where it is disclosed are unambiguous and can fit only the spiritual meaning.
Thus it could not lead into error, and only a people so carnal could misunderstand it.
For when goods are promised in abundance, what prevented them from understanding true goods, except their cupidity, which fixed this meaning on earthly goods? But those who had no good except in God referred them solely to God. For two principles divide human wills: cupidity and charity. It is not that cupidity cannot coexist with faith in God, or charity with earthly goods; but cupidity uses God and enjoys the world, and charity does the reverse.
Now the final end gives things their names. Everything that prevents us from reaching it is called an enemy. Thus creatures, though good, are enemies of the righteous when they turn them from God; and God himself is the enemy of those whose covetousness he disturbs.
Thus, since the word enemy depends on the final end, the righteous understood their passions by it, and the carnal understood the Babylonians; so these terms were obscure only to the unrighteous. That is what Isaiah says: Seal the law among my elect; and that Jesus Christ will be a stumbling stone. But “Blessed are those who will not stumble over him!” Hosea, last chapter, says it perfectly: “Where is the wise person? And he will understand what I say. The righteous will understand: for God’s ways are straight; but the wicked will stumble in them.”
B572
Hypothesis of the apostles as deceivers.
The time clearly, the manner obscurely.
Five proofs from Figurative Meanings.
2,000 { 1,600—Prophets. 400—Scattered.
B573
Blindness—from Scripture.—Scripture, the Jews said, says no one knows where the Christ will come from. John 7:27.—And 12:34. Scripture says the Christ remains eternally, and this man says he will die.
Thus, says Saint John, they did not believe, though he had performed so many miracles, so that Isaiah’s word might be fulfilled: He has blinded them, etc.
B574
Greatness.—Religion is so great a thing that it is just for those unwilling to take the trouble to seek it, if it is obscure, to be deprived of it. What, then, is there to complain of, if it is such that one can find it by seeking?
B575
Everything turns to good for the elect, even Scripture’s obscurities, for they honor them because of its divine clarities. And everything turns to evil for the others, even its clarities, for they blaspheme them because of the obscurities they do not understand.
B576
The general ordering of the world toward the Church: God wishing to blind and enlighten.—The event having proved the divinity of these prophecies, the rest must therefore be believed; and through this we see the world’s order in this way: as the miracles of creation and the flood are forgotten, God sends the law and Moses’ miracles, the prophets who prophesy particular things; and to prepare an enduring miracle, he prepares prophecies and their fulfillment. But since the prophecies might be suspect, he wishes to make them beyond suspicion, etc.
B577
God has made this people’s blindness serve the good of the elect.