Tap the page, move to the top or bottom edge, swipe down, or press Tab to reveal reading controls. Use the arrow keys or swipe sideways to turn pages.

← ExitPensées
Section VI

B374

Explanatory notes

What astonishes me most is to see that everyone is not astonished at their own weakness. People act seriously, and each follows his condition, not because it is really good to follow it, since custom ordains this, but as though each knew for certain where reason and justice lie. They find themselves deceived at every turn, and through a comical humility think that the fault is theirs, rather than the art that they always boast of possessing. But it is good that so many of these people should exist in the world, who are not Pyrrhonists, for the glory of Pyrrhonism: it shows that people are quite capable of the most extravagant opinions, since they are capable of believing that they do not suffer from this natural and unavoidable weakness, and of believing, on the contrary, that they naturally possess wisdom.

Nothing strengthens Pyrrhonism more than the existence of people who are not Pyrrhonists: if everyone were, they would be wrong.

B375

Explanatory notes

[I spent a long part of my life believing that there was justice, and I was not mistaken about that, for there is, insofar as God has wished to reveal it to us. But I did not understand it that way, and that is where I was mistaken; for I believed that our justice was essentially just and that I had the means to know and judge it. Yet I have found myself so often without sound judgment that at last I have begun to mistrust myself, and then others. I have seen every country and every person change; and so, after many changes of judgment concerning true justice, I have recognized that our nature is only continual change, and I have not changed since; and if I did change, I would confirm my opinion.

The Pyrrhonist Arcesilaus, who became dogmatic again.]

B376

This sect is strengthened by its enemies more than by its friends; for human weakness appears much more clearly in those who do not know it than in those who know it.

B377

Explanatory notes

Discourses on humility give the proud an occasion for pride and the humble an occasion for humility. In the same way, discourses on Pyrrhonism give the assertive an occasion to assert. Few speak humbly of humility, chastely of chastity, or doubtfully of Pyrrhonism. We are nothing but falsehood, duplicity, contradiction, and we conceal and disguise ourselves from ourselves.

B378

Explanatory notes

Pyrrhonism.—Too much intelligence is called madness, like an extreme lack of it. Only the middle is good. The majority has laid this down, and bites anyone who escapes it at either end. I shall not insist; I readily consent to being placed there, and I refuse to stand at the lower end, not because it is low, but because it is an end; for I would likewise refuse to be placed at the upper one. To leave the middle is to leave humanity. The greatness of the human soul consists in knowing how to remain there. So far from greatness consisting in leaving it, it consists in not leaving it.

B379

Explanatory notes

It is not good to be too free. It is not good to have everything one needs.

B380

Explanatory notes

Every good maxim is in the world already; we fail only to apply them. For example, people do not doubt that one should risk one’s life to defend the public good, and many do so; but not for religion.

There must be inequality among people: that is true; but once it is granted, the door is open not only to the greatest domination, but to the greatest tyranny.

We must let the mind relax a little: that opens the door to the greatest excesses.

Mark out the limits.—Things have no bounds: the laws try to give them some, and the mind cannot bear them.

B381

If we are too young, we do not judge well; too old, the same.

If we think about it too little, or think about it too much, we grow stubborn and become infatuated with it.

If we look at our work immediately after making it, we are still thoroughly prejudiced in its favor; if too long afterward, we [no] longer enter into it.

So it is with paintings seen from too far away—and from too close. There is only one indivisible point that is the right place; the others are too close, too far, too high, or too low. Perspective determines it in the art of painting; but in truth and morality, who will determine it?

B382

When everything moves equally, nothing appears to move, as on a ship. When everyone is heading toward excess, no one seems to be heading there; whoever stops makes the others’ headlong movement visible, like a fixed point.

B383

People living in disorder tell those living in order that they are the ones departing from nature, and believe that they themselves are following it: just as people on a ship think that those on shore are moving away. The language is the same on every side. We need a fixed point to judge. The harbor judges those on a ship; but where shall we find a harbor in morality?

B384

Being contradicted is a poor sign of truth. Many certain things are contradicted; many false things pass without contradiction. Contradiction is no sign of falsehood, nor is the absence of contradiction a sign of truth.

B385

Explanatory notes

Pyrrhonism.—Everything here is partly true and partly false. Essential truth is otherwise: it is wholly pure and wholly true; this mixture dishonors and annihilates it. Nothing is purely true; and so nothing is true, if we mean pure truth. Someone will say it is true that homicide is wrong. Yes, for we do know evil and falsehood. But what will they say is good? Chastity? I say no, for the world would end.—Marriage? No: continence is better.—Not killing? No, for the disorders would be horrible, and the wicked would kill all the good.—Killing? No, for that destroys nature.—We possess truth and goodness only in part, mixed with evil and falsehood.

Contents

Sign in to save your reading →