Tap the page, move to the top or bottom edge, swipe down, or press Tab to reveal reading controls. Use the arrow keys or swipe sideways to turn pages.

← ExitPensées
Section III

B194

Explanatory notes

…Let them at least learn what the religion they oppose is before opposing it. If this religion claimed to have a clear sight of God, possessing it openly and without a veil, it would be an objection to say that nothing in the world shows this with such clarity. But it says, on the contrary, that people are in darkness and estranged from God, that he has hidden himself from their knowledge, that this is even the name he gives himself in Scripture: “hidden God.” If, finally, it works equally to establish these two things—that God has placed perceptible signs in the Church to make himself known to sincere seekers, yet has covered them so that only those seeking him with all their hearts will perceive him—what advantage can they gain when, openly neglecting to seek truth, they cry out that nothing shows it to them? The darkness they are in, which they object against the Church, only establishes one of its assertions without touching the other. Far from ruining its teaching, it establishes it.

To oppose it, they would have to proclaim that they had made every effort to search everywhere, even in what the Church offers for their instruction, but without any satisfaction. If they spoke so, they would indeed challenge one of its claims. But I hope to show here that no reasonable person can speak that way, and I even venture to say that nobody ever has. We know well enough how people of this disposition behave. They believe they have made great efforts to inform themselves when they have spent a few hours reading some book of Scripture and questioned an ecclesiastic about the truths of faith. Afterward they boast of searching unsuccessfully among books and people. But truly, I will tell them what I have often said: such negligence is unbearable. This is not some stranger’s slight interest, to be treated in that way; it concerns ourselves and our everything.

The soul’s immortality concerns us so greatly and touches us so deeply that we must have lost all feeling to be indifferent about knowing its truth. All our actions and thoughts must take such different paths according to whether there are eternal goods to hope for that no step can be taken with sense and judgment unless it is regulated by a view of this point, which must be our ultimate object.

Thus our first interest and first duty is to gain light on this subject, on which all our conduct depends. That is why, among those not convinced of it, I make an immense distinction between those striving with all their powers to learn and those living without troubling or thinking about it.

I can feel only compassion for those who sincerely groan under this doubt, regard it as the greatest misfortune, and, sparing nothing to escape it, make this search their principal and most serious occupation.

But I regard quite differently those who pass their lives without thinking of life’s ultimate end, and who, merely because they do not themselves find the light that would convince them, neglect to seek it elsewhere or examine thoroughly whether this opinion belongs among those that people accept through credulous simplicity, or among those that, though obscure in themselves, nevertheless have a very solid and unshakable foundation.

This negligence in an affair concerning themselves, their eternity and their everything irritates me more than it moves me to tenderness. It astonishes and frightens me; it is a monstrosity to me. I do not say this from the pious zeal of spiritual devotion. On the contrary, I mean that we should feel this from a principle of human interest and an interest of self-love. We need only see what the least enlightened people see.

No very elevated soul is needed to understand that here there is no true and solid satisfaction, that all our pleasures are vanity, our evils infinite, and finally that death, threatening us every instant, must infallibly place us in a few years under the horrible necessity of being either annihilated or unhappy forever.

Nothing is more real or terrible. We may play the brave as much as we like: this is the end awaiting the finest life in the world. Reflect on it, then say whether it is not indubitable that there is good in this life only through hope of another; that we are happy only as we approach it; and that, just as there will be no further misfortunes for those who had complete assurance of eternity, there is no happiness for those who have no light concerning it.

Being in this doubt is therefore certainly a great evil; but searching when in doubt is at least an indispensable duty. Whoever doubts without seeking is at once very unhappy and very unjust. If he is also tranquil and satisfied, professes this, finally makes a vanity of it, and makes this very condition the subject of his joy and vanity, I have no words to characterize so extravagant a creature.

Where can such feelings come from? What cause for joy is there in awaiting only miseries without remedy? What cause for vanity in seeing oneself in impenetrable darkness? How can this reasoning take place in a reasonable person?

“I do not know who put me in the world, what the world is, or what I myself am. I am terribly ignorant of everything. I do not know what my body, senses or soul are, or even that part of me that thinks what I say, reflects on everything and itself, and knows itself no better than the rest. I see these terrifying spaces of the universe enclosing me, and find myself fixed to one corner of this vast extent, without knowing why I am placed here rather than elsewhere, or why this little time given me to live is assigned at this point rather than another in all the eternity preceding me and all that follows. I see only infinities everywhere, enclosing me like an atom and a shadow lasting one instant without return. All I know is that I must soon die; what I know least is this very death I cannot avoid.

“Just as I do not know where I come from, I do not know where I am going. I know only that, leaving this world, I fall forever either into nothingness or into the hands of an angry God, without knowing which of these two conditions will be my eternal share. Such is my state, full of weakness and uncertainty; and from all this I conclude that I should spend every day of my life without thinking of seeking what is to happen to me. Perhaps I could find some light upon my doubts; but I do not want to take the trouble, or a single step to seek it. Then, treating with contempt those who labor with this concern, I wish to go without foresight or fear to hazard so great an event, letting myself be softly led to death, uncertain of the eternity of my future condition.” (Whatever certainty they had, it is a subject for despair rather than vanity.)

Who would wish for a friend who speaks like this? Who would choose him among others to communicate his affairs? Who would turn to him in affliction? Finally, to what use in life could he be assigned?

Truly, it is glorious for religion to have such unreasonable people as enemies. Their opposition is so little dangerous that, on the contrary, it helps establish its truths. For the Christian faith aims almost entirely to establish these two things: nature’s corruption and redemption through Jesus Christ. I maintain that, if they do not help to show the truth of redemption through the holiness of their conduct, their unnatural feelings at least help wonderfully to show nature’s corruption.

Nothing matters to a person more than his condition; nothing is more fearful than eternity. Thus, that people should be indifferent to losing their being and to the danger of an eternity of miseries is not natural. They are altogether different toward everything else: they fear even the slightest things, foresee them, feel them. This very man, who spends so many days and nights in rage and despair over losing an office or some imaginary offense to his honor, knows without anxiety or emotion that he is about to lose everything through death. It is monstrous to see in the same heart, at the same time, this sensitivity to the smallest things and this strange insensitivity to the greatest. It is an incomprehensible enchantment, a supernatural sleep, marking the all-powerful force that causes it.

There must be a strange overturning in human nature for people to glory in this state, in which it seems incredible that even one person could exist. Yet experience shows me so many that it would be surprising if we did not know that most who meddle in it counterfeit themselves and are not really like that. They have heard that fashionable manners consist in carrying on this way; they call it shaking off the yoke, and try to imitate it. But it would not be hard to make them understand how mistaken they are in seeking esteem through it. It is no way to acquire esteem, even, I say, among worldly people who judge soundly and know that the only way to succeed is to appear decent, faithful, judicious and capable of serving a friend usefully: people naturally love only what can benefit them. What advantage is there for us in hearing someone say he has shaken off the yoke, does not believe there is a God watching his actions, considers himself sole master of his conduct, and expects to account for it only to himself? Does he think this has moved us to put great trust in him and expect consolation, advice and assistance in every need of life? Do they suppose they have delighted us by saying they hold our soul to be only a little wind and smoke, and saying it in a proud, contented voice? Is this something to say cheerfully? Ought it not, on the contrary, to be said sadly, as the saddest thing in the world?

If they thought seriously, they would see that this is so ill-conceived, so contrary to common sense, so opposed to propriety and so far in every way from the pleasing manner they seek, that they would be likelier to correct than corrupt those inclined to follow them. Indeed, make them account for their opinions and their reasons for doubting religion: they will say such weak and low things that they will persuade you of the contrary. This is what someone once said to them very aptly: “If you continue talking like this, truly you will convert me.” And he was right: who would not be horrified to find himself holding opinions in which his companions were such contemptible people?

Thus those who merely pretend these feelings would be very unfortunate to constrain their nature in order to become the most absurd people alive. If in their hearts they are distressed at having no more light, let them not conceal it: this declaration will not be shameful; the only shame is having none. Nothing more strongly accuses a mind of extreme weakness than failing to know the unhappiness of a person without God; nothing more strongly marks a badly disposed heart than failing to wish the eternal promises true; nothing is more cowardly than playing the brave against God. Let them therefore leave these impieties to those ill-disposed enough to be truly capable of them. Let them at least be decent people if they cannot be Christians, and finally acknowledge that only two kinds of people can be called reasonable: those who serve God with all their hearts because they know him, and those who seek him with all their hearts because they do not know him.

But those who live without knowing or seeking him judge themselves so unworthy of their own care that they are unworthy of others’ care. It takes all the charity of the religion they despise not to despise them to the point of abandoning them in their folly. Yet this religion obliges us, as long as they live, always to regard them as capable of the grace that can enlighten them, to believe that they may soon be fuller of faith than we are, and that we may instead fall into their blindness. We must therefore do for them what we would wish done for us in their place: call them to pity themselves and take at least some steps to try whether they might find light. Let them give this reading a few hours from those they spend so uselessly elsewhere. Whatever aversion they bring, perhaps they will encounter something, and at least they will not lose much. But for those who bring perfect sincerity and a true desire to encounter truth, I hope they will find satisfaction and be convinced by the proofs of so divine a religion that I have gathered here, in which I have followed approximately this order…

Contents

Sign in to save your reading →