Tap the page, move to the top or bottom edge, swipe down, or press Tab to reveal reading controls. Use the arrow keys or swipe sideways to turn pages.
Reading and discussion guide
How judgment begins
Begin with Pascal’s distinctions among geometric demonstration, discernment, imagination and the heart. Keep his examples in view: a word may name different acts of knowing in different settings.
1. What makes a principle difficult to notice in B1, and how does that difficulty differ from following its consequences?
2. Which claims about the heart in B282 concern first principles, and which concern the gift of faith? What changes between them?
The scales of human life
Read the two infinities beside the thinking reed and thought’s defects. Greatness and misery describe a relation that the reader has to follow through the argument, rather than two detachable verdicts.
1. Why does the ability to think alter a person’s relation to the universe without removing physical vulnerability?
2. Does B365 retract B347, or does it show what the exercise of thought must still answer for?
Occupation and the desire for happiness
B139–143, B165 and B165 bis, B172, B425
Follow the movement from an activity to the motive Pascal assigns it. Notice the difference between wanting the object pursued and wanting the pursuit itself.
1. What would count, within B139, as evidence that a person wants the hunt more than the quarry?
2. Where does Pascal’s account illuminate a familiar activity, and where does its generalization call for further argument?
Custom justice and political order
B294, B298, B310, B320 and B320 bis, B330
Read claims about force, rank and hereditary rule alongside the aim of avoiding civil war. The arguments distinguish several reasons for obeying a rule, and do not make them equally admirable.
1. When does a custom become effective, and when is it called just? Are those the same question?
2. What premise makes hereditary succession reasonable in B320 bis? How much of that argument depends on Pascal’s account of human disorder?
A choice under uncertainty
B233 in full, then B234–241 and B252
Read the whole wager rather than its most familiar exchange. Track changes of speaker, the proposed stake, the objection to choosing, and the later discussion of habit and conduct.
1. Which assumptions must an interlocutor grant before the wager’s practical recommendation follows?
2. How does the final part of B233 change the task from choosing an answer to becoming capable of belief?
Figures prophecy and their readers
B571–572, B675–677, B713, B737
Distinguish the wording of a cited passage, an event associated with it, and the Christian interpretation joining them. Pascal’s conviction about the relation does not remove the need to examine each step.
1. What does a figure preserve from the literal account, and what does Pascal say it announces beyond that account?
2. How does the continued transmission of a book function as evidence in B737? Which further conclusions require theological premises?
Christ and the orders of greatness
Compare the visibility of political power, intellectual achievement and charity. Read the examples before treating the three orders as a scheme that can simply be applied to every object.
1. Who can recognize the greatness of Archimedes, and who can recognize the greatness of Christ in B793?
2. Why can no accumulation of bodies or minds produce charity, according to the argument? What kind of difference does that claim establish?
Miracles controversy and devotional witness
B803–806, B825 and B825 bis, the questions on miracles, and the Mémorial D
Keep the voices and genres distinct: Pascal’s numbered notes, his questions, Barcos’s replies, and a devotional record. The distinction helps identify what kind of authority each text claims.
1. How do Pascal and Barcos distinguish a miraculous effect from the natural power of the means employed?
2. What does the Mémorial’s repetition communicate that an argumentative summary would lose? How does its separate source history affect its place beside the Pensées?