Tap the page, move to the top or bottom edge, swipe down, or press Tab to reveal reading controls. Use the arrow keys or swipe sideways to turn pages.

← ExitPensées
Section XIV

Section XIV

Historical thematic sequence · Brunschvicg edition

B857

Clarity, obscurity.—There would be too much obscurity if truth had no visible signs; its always being preserved in a visible Church and assembly is an admirable sign. There would be too much clarity if there were only one opinion in this Church. The one that has always been there is truth, for the true has always been there, and no false opinion has always been there.

B858

The history of the Church should properly be called the history of truth.

B859

There is pleasure in being aboard a ship battered by a storm when one is certain it will not perish: such are the persecutions that trouble the Church.

B860

After so many marks of piety, they also have persecution, the best mark of piety.

B861

A fine condition for the Church, when it is sustained by God alone.

B862

Explanatory notes

The Church has always been attacked by contrary errors, though perhaps never at the same time, as now. If it suffers more from the multiplicity of errors, it gains this advantage from them: they destroy one another.

It complains of both, but far more of the Calvinists because of schism.

It is certain that many on both opposing sides are mistaken; they must be disabused.

Faith embraces several truths that seem to contradict one another: A time to laugh, to weep, and so on. Answer, do not answer, and so on.

Their source is the union of the two natures in Jesus Christ; also the two worlds (the creation of a new heaven and new earth; new life, new death; all things doubled, with the same names remaining); finally, the two men within the righteous (for they are the two worlds and a member and image of Jesus Christ. Thus all names apply to them: righteous, sinners; dead, living; living, dead; elect, reprobate, and so on).

There are therefore many truths, both of faith and morality, that seem incompatible and yet all subsist in an admirable order. The source of all heresies is the exclusion of some of these truths; the source of all the objections heretics make against us is ignorance of some of our truths. Usually, unable to conceive the relation of two opposed truths, and believing that acknowledgment of one entails exclusion of the other, they attach themselves to one, exclude the other, and think we do the reverse. Now exclusion causes their heresy; ignorance that we hold the other truth causes their objections.

First example: Jesus Christ is God and man. The Arians, unable to join these things they believe incompatible, say he is man: in this they are Catholic. But they deny he is God: in this they are heretics. They claim we deny his humanity: in this they are ignorant.

Second example, concerning the Blessed Sacrament: We believe that, the substance of the bread having been changed—and transubstantially—into that of our Lord's body, Jesus Christ is really present there: that is one truth. Another is that this sacrament is also a figure of the sacrifice of the cross and of glory, and a commemoration of both. Such is the Catholic faith, which comprises these two seemingly opposed truths.

Today's heresy, unable to conceive that this sacrament contains together both Jesus Christ's presence and his figure, and that it is both sacrifice and commemoration of sacrifice, [believes] for this reason that one cannot admit one of these truths without excluding the other.

They attach themselves to this one point, that the sacrament is figurative; in this they are not heretics. They think we exclude this truth, hence their many objections from passages in the Fathers that state it. Finally they deny the presence; in this they are heretics.

Third example: indulgences.

Thus the shortest way to prevent heresies is to teach all the truths; the surest way to refute them is to declare them all. For what will the heretics say?

To know whether an opinion belongs to a Father…

B863

They all err the more dangerously because each follows a truth: their fault is not following a falsehood, but failing to follow another truth.

B864

Truth is so obscured in this time, and falsehood so established, that unless one loves truth, one cannot know it.

B865

Explanatory notes

If ever there is a time when both opposites should be professed, it is when one is accused of omitting one. Thus the Jesuits and Jansenists are wrong to conceal them, but the Jansenists more so, for the Jesuits have professed both better.

B866

Two kinds of people put things on the same footing: feast days with working days, Christians with priests, all sins with one another, and so on. Some conclude from this that what is wrong for priests is also wrong for Christians; others, that what is not wrong for Christians is permitted to priests.

B867

If the ancient Church was in error, the Church has fallen. Were it in error today, the case would not be the same, for it still has the higher principle of tradition handed down by the ancient Church; thus this submission and conformity to the ancient Church prevails and corrects everything. But the ancient Church did not presuppose the future Church or look toward it as we presuppose and look toward the ancient one.

B868

Explanatory notes

What spoils our comparison of what happened formerly in the Church with what we see there now is that we usually regard Saint Athanasius, Saint Teresa, and the others as crowned with glory and…as gods. Now that time has clarified things, they appear thus. But when he was persecuted, that great saint was a man called Athanasius; Saint Teresa, a woman. ‘Elijah was a man like us, subject to the same passions as us,’ says Saint Peter, to disabuse Christians of the false idea that makes us reject the saints' example as disproportionate to our condition. They were saints, we say, unlike us. What happened then? Saint Athanasius was a man called Athanasius, accused of several crimes, condemned in this and that council for this and that crime; all the bishops consented, and finally the pope. What is said to those who resist? That they disturb the peace, cause schism, and so on.

Zeal, light. Four kinds of people: zeal without knowledge; knowledge without zeal; neither knowledge nor zeal; both zeal and knowledge. The first three condemn him; the last acquit him and are excommunicated from the Church, yet save the Church.

Contents

Sign in to save your reading →