Tap the page, move to the top or bottom edge, swipe down, or press Tab to reveal reading controls. Use the arrow keys or swipe sideways to turn pages.
B815
It is not possible reasonably to believe against miracles.
B816
Unbelievers, the most credulous: they believe Vespasian's miracles so as not to believe Moses'.
B817
Title: Why people believe so many liars who say they have seen miracles, yet believe none of those who say they have secrets for making man immortal or young again.—Having considered why we place such faith in so many impostors who say they have remedies, often to the point of placing our lives in their hands, it seemed to me that the true cause is that there are genuine remedies. For it would not be possible for there to be so many false ones, or for people to give them such credence, if there were no genuine ones. Had there never been a remedy for any illness, and had all illnesses been incurable, it is impossible that people could have imagined they could provide remedies, and still more that so many others would have believed those who boasted of having them. In the same way, if a man boasted of preventing death, no one would believe him, because there is no example of this. But since many remedies have proved genuine, as even the greatest men have known, people's belief has been bent in that direction. Once this was known to be possible, people concluded that it was so. For ordinary people usually reason thus: A thing is possible; therefore it exists.—Because the thing cannot be denied in general, since particular effects are genuine, ordinary people, unable to distinguish which of these particular effects are genuine, believe them all. Likewise, what makes people believe so many false effects of the moon is that some are real, such as the sea's tides.
The same holds for prophecies, miracles, divination through dreams, spells, and so on. For if nothing in all this had ever been genuine, no one would ever have believed any of it. Thus, instead of concluding that there are no true miracles because there are so many false ones, we must say, on the contrary, that there certainly are true miracles, since there are so many false ones, and that false ones exist only because true ones exist. We must reason in the same way about religion, for it would not be possible for people to have imagined so many false religions if there were not one true religion. The objection is that savages have a religion; but the answer is that they have heard of it, as appears from the Flood, circumcision, Saint Andrew's cross, and so on.
B818
Having considered why there are so many false miracles, false revelations, spells, and so on, it seemed to me that the true cause is that there are genuine ones. For there could not be so many false miracles if there were no genuine ones, nor so many false revelations if there were no genuine ones, nor so many false religions if there were not one true religion. For if none of all this had ever existed, it is almost impossible that people could have imagined it, and still more impossible that so many others would have believed it. But since there have been very great genuine things, believed as such by great men, this impression caused almost everyone to become capable of believing false ones too. Thus, instead of concluding that there are no true miracles because there are so many false ones, we must say, on the contrary, that there are true miracles because there are so many false ones, and that false ones exist only because true ones exist; and likewise that false religions exist only because one true religion exists.—The objection: that savages have a religion. But they have heard of the true one, as appears from Saint Andrew's cross, the Flood, circumcision, and so on. This comes from the human mind's being bent in that direction by truth and thus becoming receptive to all the falsehoods of this…
B819
Jeremiah 23:32, the miracles of false prophets. In the Hebrew and Vatablus it reads frivolities.
Miracle does not always mean miracle. 1 Kings 14:15: miracle means fear, and so it reads in the Hebrew. Likewise, plainly, in Job 33:7. Again Isaiah 21:4; Jeremiah 44:12. Portentum, ‘portent,’ means simulacrum, ‘image,’ Jeremiah 50:38; so it reads in the Hebrew and Vatablus. Isaiah 8:18. Jesus Christ says that he and his own will be as miracles.
B820
If the devil favored the doctrine that destroys him, he would be divided, as Jesus Christ said. If God favored the doctrine that destroys the Church, he would be divided: Every kingdom divided… For Jesus Christ acted against the devil and destroyed his dominion over hearts, of which exorcism is the figure, to establish God's kingdom. Thus he adds: If by the finger of God…the kingdom of God has come to you.
B821
There is a great difference between putting to the test and leading into error. God puts to the test, but does not lead into error. To put to the test is to provide occasions that impose no necessity, in which, if someone does not love God, he will do a certain thing. To lead into error is to place a person under the necessity of concluding and following a falsehood.
B822
Abraham, Gideon: [signs] above revelation. The Jews blinded themselves by judging miracles by Scripture. God has never abandoned his true worshipers.
I prefer to follow Jesus Christ rather than anyone else, because he has miracles, prophecies, doctrine, perpetuity, and so on.
Donatists: no miracle that obliges us to say it is the devil. The more one particularizes God, Jesus Christ, the Church…
B823
If there were no false miracles, there would be certainty. If there were no rule for distinguishing them, miracles would be useless and there would be no reason to believe.
Now, humanly speaking, there is no human certainty, but there is reason.
B824
Either God has confounded false miracles or he has foretold them; by either means he has risen above what is supernatural in relation to us, and has raised us above it ourselves.
B825
Miracles serve not to convert but to condemn. (1st part, 113, art. 10, reply 2.)
B825 bis
Miracles.—Saint Thomas, vol. III, book VIII, chapter 20.